Diversity is increasing and processes such as ‘Me Too’ and ‘Black Lives Matter’ have brought issues of diversity to the fore. In the present chapter, we emphasise that in an increasingly diverse world, higher education institutions need to actively put diversity on the blackboard, and explore the nexus between teaching, diversity, and awareness. Through a framework of cultural psychology, we unpack four key aspects related to this nexus: First, we explore diversity teaching. Second, we look at structural diversity, i.e., student body composition, as well as that of the faculty. Third, we pay particular attention to processes of ‘us and them’. Fourth, we look at the need for diverse knowledge. Taking a broad approach to issues of diversity and inclusion, higher education institutions must engage actively with the connection between diversity, teaching, and awareness as it is pivotal in an increasingly super-diverse world.