On the challenges of drawing conclusions fromp-values just below 0.05
Author:
Open Access
Abstract
In recent years, researchers have attempted to provide an indication of the prevalence of inflated Type 1 error rates by analyzing the distribution of p-values in the published literature. De Winter & Dodou (2015) analyzed the distribution (and its change over time) of a large number of p-values automatically extracted from abstracts in the scientific literature. They concluded there is a ‘surge of p-values between 0.041–0.049 in recent decades’ which ‘suggests (but does not prove) questionable research practices have increased over the past 25 years.’ I show the changes in the ratio of fractions of p-values between 0.041–0.049 over the years are better explained by assuming the average power has decreased over time. Furthermore, I propose that their observation that p-values just below 0.05 increase more strongly than p-values above 0.05 can be explained by an increase in publication bias (or the file drawer effect) over the years (cf. Fanelli, 2012; Pautasso, 2010, which has led to a relative decrease of ‘marginally significant’ p-values in abstracts in the literature (instead of an increase in p-values just below 0.05). I explain why researchers analyzing large numbers of p-values need to relate their assumptions to a model of p-value distributions that takes into account the average power of the performed studies, the ratio of true positives to false positives in the literature, the effects of publication bias, and the Type 1 error rate (and possible mechanisms through which it has inflated). Finally, I discuss why publication bias and underpowered studies might be a bigger problem for science than inflated Type 1 error rates, and explain the challenges when attempting to draw conclusions about inflated Type 1 error rates from a large heterogeneous set of p-values.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Publication Bias in Psychology: A Diagnosis Based on the Correlation between Effect Size and Sample SizePLOS ONE, 2014
- Sailing From the Seas of Chaos Into the Corridor of StabilityPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2014
- Registered ReportsSocial Psychology, 2014
- The Alleged Crisis and the Illusion of Exact ReplicationPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2014
- The Life of p: “Just Significant” Results are on the RiseQuarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2013
- Power failure: why small sample size undermines the reliability of neuroscienceNature Reviews Neuroscience, 2013
- A peculiar prevalence of p values just below .05Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2012
- False-Positive PsychologyPsychological Science, 2011
- Replication and p Intervals: p Values Predict the Future Only Vaguely, but Confidence Intervals Do Much BetterPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2008
- Do studies of statistical power have an effect on the power of studies?Psychological Bulletin, 1989