Rethinking Exams and Letter Grades: How Much Can Teachers Delegate to Students?
Authors:
- John D. BellJBJohn D. Bell
- Jeffrey SchinskeJSJeffrey Schinske
- Kimberly TannerKTKimberly Tanner
- Jennifer NelsonJNJennifer Nelson
- Monitoring Editor Paul WilliamsMWMonitoring Editor Paul Williams
- Adrienne E. WilliamsAWAdrienne E. Williams
- Nancy M. Aguilar-RocaNANancy M. Aguilar-Roca
- 1 September 2006
- journal article
- Published by American Society for Cell Biology (ASCB) in CBE—Life Sciences Education
- Vol. 5 (3) , 270-280
Abstract
In this article we report a 3-yr study of a large-enrollment Cell Biology course focused on developing student skill in scientific reasoning and data interpretation. Specifically, the study tested the hypothesis that converting the role of exams from summative grading devices to formative tools would increase student success in acquiring those skills. Traditional midterm examinations were replaced by weekly assessments administered under test-like conditions and followed immediately by extensive self, peer, and instructor feedback. Course grades were criterion based and derived using data from the final exam. To alleviate anxiety associated with a single grading instrument, students were given the option of informing the grading process with evidence from weekly assessments. A comparative analysis was conducted to determine the impact of these design changes on both performance and measures of student affect. Results at the end of each year were used to inform modifications to the course in subsequent years. Significant improvements in student performance and attitudes were observed as refinements were implemented. The findings from this study emphasized the importance of prolonging student opportunity and motivation to improve by delaying grade decisions, providing frequent and immediate performance feedback, and designing that feedback to be maximally formative and minimally punitive.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exemplars as Case Studies: Reflections on the Links Between Theory, Practice, and ContextAmerican Journal of Evaluation, 2004
- A Student-Centered Approach to Teaching General Biology That Really Works: Lord's Constructivist Model Put to a TestThe American Biology Teacher, 2003
- Teaching Cell Biology in the Large-Enrollment Classroom: Methods to Promote Analytical Thinking and Assessment of Their EffectivenessCell Biology Education, 2003
- Assessment and Active Learning Strategies for Introductory Geology CoursesJournal of Geoscience Education, 2003
- The "testing" phenomenon: Not gone but nearly forgotten.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1989
- The Impact of Classroom Evaluation Practices on StudentsReview of Educational Research, 1988
- Effects of no feedback, task-related comments, and grades on intrinsic motivation and performance.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1986
- External Evaluation, Task Difficulty, and Continuing MotivationThe Journal of Educational Research, 1985
- Quality of Learning With an Active Versus Passive Motivational SetAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1984