Variation in Resistance of Field Populations of Tobacco Budworm and Bollworm (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) to Selected Insecticides

Authors:

Abstract
The pyre thyroids fenvalerate, permethrin, cypermethrin, deltamethrin, and cyfluthrin were tested against laboratory strains of the boll worm, Helios this zea (Baddie), and tobacco Budworm, Helios this viruses (F.). No differences in susceptibility were observed when the two species were exposed to the same pyre throed. LD50’s for all of the pyrethroids were significantly lower for both species than LD50’s for methomyl, methyl parathion, and profenofos. Field strains of tobacco budworms collected in Louisiana, Texas, Arizona, and Mississippiduring 1985 and 1986 exhibited low to high levels of resistance to fenvalerate (2-to 35-fold), permethrin (1- to 74-fold) and cypermethrin (2- to 9-fold) with considerable variation among strains and years. Failures of pyrethroids to provide adequate control in the field and the large reduction in susceptibility in laboratory tests against larvae from the problem areas indicate that tobacco budworm resistance to pyrethroid insecticides has reached a problem level. When tested in successive generations with fenvalerate, a highly resistant strain of the tobacco budworm exhibited a 2-fold reduction in resistance at the LD50 and a 13-fold reduction at the LD90from the F1 to the F2 laboratory generation.