Despite, or because of, theories that problematize concepts of performance audience, few recent studies of audience exist. This paper ponders the relative lack of audience studies, considers obstacles to them, and demonstrates the complexities of audiencing through an exploration of selected Playback Theatre performances. Playback Theatre's characteristics evidence an ancient and yet innovative type of social activism by featuring audience members, giving them agency in the performance, and empowering them to share values and experiences, argue with, and support others through story. Playback Theatre involves a blurring of roles where performers become audience members and audience members become performers; it provides a metaphorical language where performances "answer" performances; and it invites a performative method of research and reporting that features interrogating over evaluating.