This study examines thunderstorms on 22 May 2019 in Oklahoma, where strong instability and wind shear existed along a synoptic boundary and across a relatively broad warm sector and was forecasted to support long-lived supercells and tornadoes. Two particularly dangerous situation tornado watches were issued during the event, but only three hail reports and no tornadoes formed in the watch that covered the southwestern portion of the state. Several tornadic supercells and many more severe reports occurred in the watch in the northeastern part of Oklahoma. This study uses analysis data from the High-Resolution Rapid Refresh model to examine how variability in mesoscale environments on 22 May 2019 can likely explain differences in storm severity between the two regions. The most notable environmental differences in this event were between western and eastern parts of the warm sector. Both areas had low-level bulk wind difference, low-level storm relative helicity, lifting condensation level height, and significant tornado parameter values that were within the expected climatological range for significantly tornadic supercells, and both were characterized by several rounds of convection initiation. However, differences in low-level vertical wind shear combined with drier midlevel conditions and a more prominent reduction in midlevel buoyancy (associated with an elevated mixed layer) in the western part of the warm sector appeared to substantially limit severe hazard production.