Subject indexing in humanities: a comparison between a local university repository and an international bibliographic service
Authors:
- 23 May 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Documentation
- Vol. 76 (6) , 1193-1214
Abstract
Purpose: As the humanities develop in the realm of increasingly more pronounced digital scholarship, it is important to provide quality subject access to a vast range of heterogeneous information objects in digital services. The study aims to paint a representative picture of the current state of affairs of the use of subject index terms in humanities journal articles with particular reference to the well-established subject access needs of humanities researchers, with the purpose of identifying which improvements are needed in this context.Design/methodology/approach: The comparison of subject metadata on a sample of 649 peer-reviewed journal articles from across the humanities is conducted in a university repository, against Scopus, the former reflecting local and national policies and the latter being the most comprehensive international abstract and citation database of research output.Findings: The study shows that established bibliographic objectives to ensure subject access for humanities journal articles are not supported in either the world's largest commercial abstract and citation database Scopus or the local repository of a public university in Sweden. The indexing policies in the two services do not seem to address the needs of humanities scholars for highly granular subject index terms with appropriate facets; no controlled vocabularies for any humanities discipline are used whatsoever.Originality/value: In all, not much has changed since 1990s when indexing for the humanities was shown to lag behind the sciences. The community of researchers and information professionals, today working together on digital humanities projects, as well as interdisciplinary research teams, should demand that their subject access needs be fulfilled, especially in commercial services like Scopus and discovery services.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Potential and Challenges of Subject Access in Libraries Today on the Example of Swedish LibrariesThe International Information & Library Review, 2016
- Characteristics of tagging behavior in digitized humanities online collectionsJournal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2015
- Researchers' information needs in the bibliographic database: A literature reviewInformation Services and Use, 2014
- Evaluation and Comparison of Discovery Tools: An UpdateInformation Technology and Libraries, 2014
- The Choice Is Yours! Researchers Assign Subject Metadata to Their Own Materials in Institutional RepositoriesCataloging & Classification Quarterly, 2013
- Discovery Tools and Information LiteracyJournal of Web Librarianship, 2011
- Usability of the VuFind Next-Generation Online CatalogInformation Technology and Libraries, 2011
- Where Keywords Fail: Using Metadata to Facilitate Digital Humanities ScholarshipJournal of Library Metadata, 2008
- Subject Retrieval from Full-Text Databases in the Humanitiesportal: Libraries and the Academy, 2007
- The Getty End-User Online Searching Project in the Humanities: Report No. 6: Overview and ConclusionsCollege and Research Libraries, 1996