Marine ecosystems model development should be rooted in past experiences, not anchored in old habits
Authors:
- 3 December 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 77 (1) , 46-57
Abstract
Numerical models of marine ecosystems tend to increase in complexity, incorporating a growing number of functions and parameters. Here, we reflect on the issue of “anchoring” inherent to model development, i.e. the tendency for modellers to take processes, functional forms and parameters from previous studies as granted. We focused on the particular example of the parameterization of temperature-dependent ontogeny in Calanus spp. copepods. We could identify 68 studies that implemented and parameterized this functional relationship. Semantic analysis identified distinct clusters of research scopes and coauthor networks. We showed that biases in parameters origin have the potential to produce misleading results, while recent experimental studies were often not assimilated into contemporary modelling studies. Anchoring involves external constraints in numerical models' development such as conceptual gaps and data scarcity, as well as internal drivers such as academic ontogeny and cultural background of the modeller. Retrospective quantitative literature analyses help identify how biases have worked their way into the collective understanding and help to suggest ways forward for the research community. These involve implementation of revision management systems for parameters and functional forms as already exists for numerical codes, and, as always, a more efficient dialogue between modellers, experimentalists and field ecologists.Keywords
Funding Information
- NSERC Discovery (RGPIN-2014-05433, OCE-1459096, OAC-1636848)
This publication has 89 references indexed in Scilit:
- Decision-making in model construction: Unveiling habitsEnvironmental Modelling & Software, 2019
- A high-resolution modeling study on diel and seasonal vertical migrations of high-latitude copepodsEcological Modelling, 2018
- Copepod Life Strategy and Population Viability in Response to Prey Timing and Temperature: Testing a New Model across Latitude, Time, and the Size SpectrumFrontiers in Marine Science, 2016
- Traits controlling body size in copepods: separating general constraints from species-specific strategiesMarine Ecology Progress Series, 2016
- Validation of an Eulerian population model for the marine copepod Calanus finmarchicus in the Norwegian SeaJournal of Marine Systems, 2016
- Dysfunctionality in ecosystem models: An underrated pitfall?Progress in Oceanography, 2010
- Dynamics of coexisting Calanus finmarchicus, Calanus glacialis and Calanus hyperboreus populations in a high-Arctic fjordPolar Biology, 2005
- Growth and development rates of the copepod Calanus finmarchicus reared in the laboratoryMarine Ecology Progress Series, 2001
- A realistic physical-biological model forCalanus finmarchicusin the North AtlanticOphelia, 1996
- Starvation tolerance, development time and egg production of Calanoides carinatus in the Southern Benguela CurrentJournal of Plankton Research, 1986