The case of the disappearing librarians: analyzing documentation of librarians’ contributions to systematic reviews
Open Access
- 24 March 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University Library System, University of Pittsburgh in Journal of the Medical Library Association
- Vol. 110 (4) , 409-418
Abstract
Objective: The study aimed to analyze the documented role of a librarian in published systematic reviews and meta-analyses whose registered protocols mentioned librarian involvement. The intention was to identify how, or if, librarians’ involvement was formally documented, how their contributions were described, and if there were any potential connections between this documentation and basic metrics of search reproducibility and quality. Methods: Reviews whose PROSPERO protocols were registered in 2017 and 2018 and that also specifically mentioned a librarian were analyzed for documentation of the librarian’s involvement. Language describing the librarian and their involvement was gathered and coded, and additional information about the review, including search strategy details, was also collected. Results: A total of 209 reviews were found and analyzed. Of these, 28% had a librarian co-author, 41% named a librarian in the acknowledgements section, and 78% mentioned the contribution of a librarian within the body of the review. However, mentions of a librarian within the review were often generic (“a librarian”) and in 31% of all reviews analyzed no librarian was specified by name. In 9% of the reviews, there was no reference to a librarian found at all. Conclusions: Even among this set of reviews, where librarian involvement was specified at the protocol level, librarians’ contributions were often described with minimal, or even no, language in the final published review. Much room for improvement appears to remain in terms of how librarians’ work is documented.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Where in the World Is This Research Taking Us? Collaborating on Publishable Research With Undergraduates AbroadFrontiers in Psychology, 2019
- Arterial Spin-Labeling in Children with Brain Tumor: A Meta-AnalysisAmerican Journal of Neuroradiology, 2018
- It takes longer than you think: librarian time spent on systematic review tasksJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2018
- Roles for librarians in systematic reviews: a scoping reviewJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2018
- Collaboration challenges in systematic reviews: a survey of health sciences librariansJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2017
- Impact of librarians on reporting of the literature searching component of pediatric systematic reviewsJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2016
- Increasing value and reducing waste in biomedical research: librarians are listening and are part of the answer.The Lancet, 2016
- Librarian co-authors correlated with higher quality reported search strategies in general internal medicine systematic reviewsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2015
- Use of Recommended Search Strategies in Systematic Reviews and the Impact of Librarian Involvement: A Cross-Sectional Survey of Recent AuthorsPLOS ONE, 2015
- Best Practice in Systematic Reviews: The Importance of Protocols and RegistrationPLOS Medicine, 2011