A League of Their Own? Evaluating Justifications for The Division of Sport into ‘Enhanced’ and ‘Unenhanced’ Leagues
Author:
- 28 February 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Sport, Ethics and Philosophy
- Vol. 6 (1) , 31-45
Abstract
Cheating through the use of illegal performance enhancements (such as doping) is a persistent problem in sport. It has been suggested that one response to this problem is to separate sport into two parallel leagues. One league would resemble sport as it is currently practised – i.e. with restrictions on use of particular enhancements – and the other would not possess these restrictions, allowing those that wish to use currently illegal enhancements to do so. In this paper I articulate the ‘two leagues’ proposal further and subject it to critical scrutiny. The proposal fails. It does so by failing to address conceptual confusion regarding enhancement use in sport; by replicating in the new league the current problems associated with enhancement-based cheating; and by creating new problems. In an attempt to revive it I describe other possible justifications for the proposal, based on its promotion of personal autonomy, and rights-based justifications. These fail, with the exception of a group right claiming provision of the enhanced league as a participatory good. I conclude that this latter use of the proposal is the only sensible one, but it nevertheless faces significant obstacles.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ethics of Human Enhancement: 25 Questions & AnswersStudies in Ethics, Law, and Technology, 2010
- Athletic Perfection, Performance-Enhancing Drugs, and the Treatment-Enhancement DistinctionJournal of the Philosophy of Sport, 2009
- Can Communal Goods be Human Rights?European Journal of Sociology, 2009
- Does the biomedical revolution spell the end of sport?British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2008
- The Doping DilemmaScientific American, 2008
- Pistorius ineligible for the Olympic Games: the right decision: Figure 1British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2008
- On the argument that enhancement is “cheating”Journal of Medical Ethics, 2008
- Rethinking Enhancement in SportAnnals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2006
- Why we should allow performance enhancing drugs in sportBritish Journal of Sports Medicine, 2004
- Individuals, Groups, and Rights to Public GoodsUniversity of Toronto Law Journal, 1988