Is it morally problematic to manipulate people online in order to get, say, their attention, their data, their money, or even their political vote? If so, what makes it wrong exactly? When confronted with practices involving (apparent) online manipulation, common reactions include pointing out how such practices threaten or violate personal autonomy (Nys and Engelen in this volume; Keeling and Burr in this volume; Susser, Roessler, and Nissenbaum 2019; Williams 2018). When it comes to political micro-targeting in particular, that is, tailoring online political messages to specific individuals, scholars further stress the potentially growing information asymmetry between citizens and political actors and the risks posed for “voter manipulation” or how one’s autonomy in the political domain is affected and the threats posed to democracy as a result (Barocas 2012; Zuiderveen Borgesius et al. 2018).