The Fake Fat Phenomenon in Organizing Pleuritis

Authors:
  • PCPhilip Cagle
    Philip Cagle
  • TCThomas V. Colby
    Thomas V. Colby
  • JCJoseph M. Corson
    Joseph M. Corson
  • AGAllen R. Gibbs
    Allen R. Gibbs
  • SHSamuel Hammar
    Samuel Hammar
  • NONelson Ordonez
    Nelson Ordonez
  • VRVictor L. Roggli
    Victor L. Roggli
  • HTHenry D. Tazelaar
    Henry D. Tazelaar
  • WTWilliam D. Travis
    William D. Travis
Publisher website
Google Scholar
Abstract
We report 9 patients with pleural biopsies referred because of concern about infiltration of what appeared to be chest wall fat by pan-keratin-positive spindled cells, a finding that led to a consideration of desmoplastic mesothelioma. All patients showed pleural effusions/pleural thickening on computed tomographic scan. Pleural biopsy showed a greatly thickened and fibrotic paucicellular pleura with circular fat-like spaces and, sometimes, adjacent oblate spaces mostly deep in the fibrotic area. Indistinct, keratin-positive, spindle cells arranged parallel to the pleural surface coursed between these fat-like spaces. S-100 stains were negative around the fat-like spaces. Vimentin stains showed that the spaces did not have a cellular lining of any kind. Sometimes the spaces contained faintly hematoxyphilic material that was Alcian blue positive, and similar material was seen in the fibrotic stroma. Follow-up with periods ranging from 6 to 30 months revealed that 8 cases had stable disease on chest imaging or by clinical findings. One case had slowly progressive pleural thickening. These observations suggest that spaces resembling fat may be encountered in fibrotic pleurae and that horizontally oriented keratin-positive spindled cells between the fat-like spaces deep in the fibrotic portion of a thickened pleura represent a benign finding seen in some cases of organizing pleuritis/fibrothorax. The spaces themselves are probably artifacts derived from the biopsy procedure and/or cutting artifacts. In contrast, in true desmoplastic mesotheliomas there is downward, rather than horizontal, growth of keratin-positive spindled cells running between clearly definable fat cells.