Is Competency Assessment at the Specialist Level Achievable? A Study for the National Training Programme in Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery in England
Authors:
- Melody NiMNMelody Ni
- Susannah M. WylesSWSusannah M. Wyles
- Robin H. KennedyRKRobin H. Kennedy
- Nader K. FrancisNFNader K. Francis
- Amjad ParvaizAPAmjad Parvaiz
- Chris CunninghamCCChris Cunningham
- Timothy A. RockallTRTimothy A. Rockall
- Andrew M. GudgeonAGAndrew M. Gudgeon
- Mark G. ColemanMCMark G. Coleman
- George B. HannaGHGeorge B. Hanna
- 1 March 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Annals of Surgery
- Vol. 257 (3) , 476-482
Abstract
To develop, validate, and implement a competency assessment tool (CAT) for technical surgical performance in the context of a summative assessment process for the National Training Programme in Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery (NTP). The NTP is an educational initiative by the National Cancer Action Team in England to safely increase the uptake of laparoscopic colorectal surgery. It is the first competency-based national educational initiative for specialist surgeons (consultants), and performance assessment is an integral part of the program. Content validity was sought using expert opinion by semistructured interviews and the Delphi method. For validity and reliability studies, NTP apprentices and experts were asked to submit video-recorded cases. Construct validity was established between delegates who passed the assessment and those who failed. Concurrent validity was tested by comparing scores with error counts as identified by observational clinical human reliability analysis. A fully crossed design, using generalizability theory methods and D-studies, was used for reliability. Interviews and the Delphi method revealed a list of characteristics for assessment. A hybrid structure combining task-specific and generic items was used to include important characteristics into the assessment format. Fifty-four cases were submitted. Overall reliability reached G(ACI) = 0.803 when using 2 cases and 2 assessors. Experts scored significantly better than apprentices (3.19 vs 2.60; P = 0.004), and apprentices who passed had better scores than those who failed (2.95 vs 2.28; P < 0.001). There was an inverse correlation between CAT scores and observational clinical human reliability analysis error counts (ρ = −0.520, P < 0.001). The combination of both methods reached overall sensitivity of 100%, specificity of 83.3%, a positive predictive value of 93.8%, and a negative predictive value of 100%. The CAT can reliably assess technical performance in laparoscopic colorectal surgery. The use of CATs to judge specialist technical performance before embarking on independent practice of new procedures is achievable on a national scale and can be adapted by other specialties.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Observational tools for assessment of procedural skills: a systematic reviewThe American Journal of Surgery, 2011
- The National Training Programme for Laparoscopic Colorectal Surgery in England: a new training paradigmColorectal Disease, 2011
- Systematic Review on Mentoring and Simulation in Laparoscopic Colorectal SurgeryAnnals of Surgery, 2010
- Development, validation and implementation of a monitoring tool for training in laparoscopic colorectal surgery in the English National Training ProgramSurgical Endoscopy, 2010
- Impact of established skills in open surgery on the proficiency gain process for laparoscopic surgerySurgical Endoscopy, 2010
- A Multivariate Analysis of Potential Risk Factors for Intra- and Postoperative Complications in 1316 Elective Laparoscopic Colorectal ProceduresAnnals of Surgery, 2008
- Construct validation of a novel hybrid virtual-reality simulator for training and assessing laparoscopic colectomy; results from the first course for experienced senior laparoscopic surgeonsSurgical Endoscopy, 2008
- Pay for Performance at the Tipping PointNew England Journal of Medicine, 2007
- Assessment in Medical EducationNew England Journal of Medicine, 2007
- Predicting conversion in laparoscopic colorectal surgerySurgical Endoscopy, 2003