The English Teaching Excellence (and Student Outcomes) Framework: Intelligent accountability in higher education?
Authors:
Open Access
- 3 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Educational Change
- Vol. 21 (1) , 215-243
Abstract
This paper explores what underlies the recent introduction of a Higher Education Teaching Excellence Framework (TEF) in England. Related changes to the higher education landscape are discussed: the 2017 Higher Education Act and creation of a new HE regulator, the Office for Students. How TEF works and some of the consequences of TEF are outlined. As well as discussing what constitutes teaching excellence and what TEF itself is attempting to signal (which includes graduate destinations), we also analyse the underpinning ideologies and logics of choosing metrics to assess teaching excellence, albeit accompanied by peer panel evaluation of institutional written submissions, in determining Gold, Silver and Bronze TEF outcomes. We introduce the notion of TEF as an index rather than a measure. It is suggested that what underlies the English TEF is not about improving teaching but rather an endeavour to pit universities against each other in a highly marketised competitive system with an oversupply of places, in which student debt levels are rising fast. TEF policy is considered with respect to features that would be required of an intelligent accountability system for higher education teaching quality.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding comparability of examination standardsResearch Papers in Education, 2010
- Contrasting conceptions of comparabilityResearch Papers in Education, 2010
- Leveling the Playing Field: Should Student Evaluation Scores be Adjusted?*Social Science Quarterly, 2007
- Determinants of How Students Evaluate TeachersThe Journal of Economic Education, 2006
- Management as ideology: the case of ‘new managerialism’ in higher educationOxford Review of Education, 2005
- Do Higher Grades Lead to Favorable Student Evaluations?The Journal of Economic Education, 2005
- Would the real gold standard please step forward?Research Papers in Education, 2000
- Dimensions of excellence in university teachingInternational Journal for Academic Development, 1998
- Examining standards over timeResearch Papers in Education, 1997
- The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social ActionAmerican Sociological Review, 1936