What are the strengths and limitations to utilising creative methods in public and patient involvement in health and social care research? A qualitative systematic review
Open Access
- 13 May 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Involvement and Engagement
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-13
Abstract
Background: There is increasing interest in using patient and public involvement (PPI) in research to improve the quality of healthcare. Ordinarily, traditional methods have been used such as interviews or focus groups. However, these methods tend to engage a similar demographic of people. Thus, creative methods are being developed to involve patients for whom traditional methods are inaccessible or non-engaging. Objective: To determine the strengths and limitations to using creative PPI methods in health and social care research. Method: Electronic searches were conducted over five databases on 14th April 2023 (Web of Science, PubMed, ASSIA, CINAHL, Cochrane Library). Studies that involved traditional, non-creative PPI methods were excluded. Creative PPI methods were used to engage with people as research advisors, rather than study participants. Only primary data published in English from 2009 were accepted. Title, abstract and full text screening was undertaken by two independent reviewers before inductive thematic analysis was used to generate themes. Results: Twelve papers met the inclusion criteria. The creative methods used included songs, poems, drawings, photograph elicitation, drama performance, visualisations, social media, photography, prototype development, cultural animation, card sorting and persona development. Analysis identified four limitations and five strengths to the creative approaches. Limitations included the time and resource intensive nature of creative PPI, the lack of generalisation to wider populations and ethical issues. External factors, such as the lack of infrastructure to support creative PPI, also affected their implementation. Strengths included the disruption of power hierarchies and the creation of a safe space for people to express mundane or “taboo” topics. Creative methods are also engaging, inclusive of people who struggle to participate in traditional PPI and can also be cost and time efficient. Conclusion: ‘Creative PPI’ is an umbrella term encapsulating many different methods of engagement and there are strengths and limitations to each. The choice of which should be determined by the aims and requirements of the research, as well as the characteristics of the PPI group and practical limitations. Creative PPI can be advantageous over more traditional methods, however a hybrid approach could be considered to reap the benefits of both. Creative PPI methods are not widely used; however, this could change over time as PPI becomes embedded even more into research.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Social Care and Health Research (135190, 135190, 135190, 135190, 135190, 135190, 135190)
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Patient and public involvement in randomised clinical trials: a mixed-methods study of a clinical trials unit to identify good practice, barriers and facilitatorsTrials, 2021
- Acceptability of risk‐stratified population screening across cancer types: Qualitative interviews with the Australian publicHealth Expectations, 2021
- The rationale and design of public involvement in health-funding decision making: focus groups with the Canadian publicInternational Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 2020
- Understanding and optimising patient and public involvement in trial oversight: an ethnographic study of eight clinical trialsTrials, 2020
- Health TAPESTRY: co-designing interprofessional primary care programs for older adults using the persona-scenario methodBMC Family Practice, 2019
- Frameworks for supporting patient and public involvement in research: Systematic review and co‐design pilotHealth Expectations, 2019
- Try to see it my way: exploring the co-design of visual presentations of wellbeing through a workshop processPerspectives in Public Health, 2019
- Cultural animation in health research: An innovative methodology for patient and public involvement and engagementHealth Expectations, 2018
- Qualitative systematic reviews: their importance for our understanding of research relevant to painBritish Journal of Pain, 2014
- Beyond tokenistic participation: Using representational artefacts to enable meaningful public participation in health service designHealth Policy, 2013