Addressing the Problem of Brain Death Misdiagnosis
Open Access
- 28 May 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics
- Vol. 53 (2) , 244-253
Abstract
Recent literature describes the controversy relating to brain death/death by neurological criteria (DNC), which some have referred to as “widely accepted, but not universally supported.” This article provides an overview of differences in state laws relating to DNC and describes recent proposals to reform the definition of brain death. In 2023, the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) issued clinical guidelines stating that clinicians may declare a patient DNC despite evidence of neuroendocrine function — a position that directly conflicts with state law requirements for determining death. This article offers a critical analysis of AAN guidelines, an update on proposals to reform the Uniform Determination of Death Act, and explains why policy discussions should include how DNC exams occur in practice. Research suggests there are flaws with current clinical testing methods, which contributes to two separate problems: (1) false positives from insufficient testing, and (2) inadvertent misdiagnosis from unintentional errors. Together, this has produced confusion and reduced public trust in the concept of brain death. This article provides recommendations to clarify and retain the current legal standard for brain death, explains the ethical importance of accurate standards for determining DNC, and offers practical solutions to reduce errors.Keywords
Funding Information
- Morsani College of Medicine (F-112622)
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Quest to Revise the Uniform Determination of Death Act: Why We Tried, Why We Failed, and Where We Go from HereNeurocritical Care, 2024
- The Uncertain Future of the Determination of Brain DeathJAMA, 2023
- The Uniform Determination of Death Act is Being RevisedNeurocritical Care, 2022
- What Should We Do When Families Refuse Testing for Brain Death?AMA Journal of Ethics, 2020
- What Does the Public Need to Know About Brain Death?AMA Journal of Ethics, 2020
- What Should We Do About the Mismatch Between Legal Criteria for Death and How Brain Death Is Diagnosed?AMA Journal of Ethics, 2020
- Should a Patient Who Is Pregnant and Brain Dead Receive Life Support, Despite Objection From Her Appointed Surrogate?AMA Journal of Ethics, 2020
- Brain Death and the Law: Hard Cases and Legal ChallengesHastings Center Report, 2018
- Contemporary Legal Updates to the Definition of Brain Death in NevadaJAMA Neurology, 2017
- A Definition of Irreversible ComaJAMA, 1968