Comparison of cephalometric analysis using a non-radiographic sonic digitizer (DigiGraphTM Workstation) with conventional radiography
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 February 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Orthodontics
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-13
Abstract
Cephalometric analysis conventionally requires radiographic exposure which may not be compatible with the growing concern over radiation hazards. Recently, the Dolphin Workstation Imaging System introduced to the dental profession a non-radiographic system, called the DigiGraph™ Workstation which may be an alternative to cephalometric radiography. The aims of this study were to compare the validity and reproducibility of cephalometric measurements obtained from the DigiGraph™ Workstation with conventional cephalometric radiographs. The sample consisted of 30 human dry skulls. Two replicated sets of lateral cephalograms were obtained with steel ball markers placed at the majority of the cephalometric landmarks. Duplicate tracings prepared from each radiograph were digitized to obtain cephalometric measurements using the computer software, Dentofacial Planner. For the DigiGraph™ Workstation, double sonic digitizations were repeated twice for each skull, on two occasions. Fifteen angular and one linear measurement were obtained from both methods and these findings compared using ANOVA, paired t-tests and F-tests. All, except one, cephalometric measurement showed significant differences between the two methods (P<0.0001). The DigiGraph™ Workstation consistently produced higher values in 11 measurements (mean differences +0.5 to +15.7 degrees or mm) and lower values in four measurements (mean differences -0.2 to -3.5 degrees). The standard deviations of the differences between readings of both methods were large (0.4-5.8 degrees or mm). The reproducibility of the DigiGraph™ Workstation measurements was lower than that of the radiographic measurements. The method error of the DigiGraph™ Workstation ranged from 7 to 70 per cent, while that of radiographic tracings was less than 2 per cent. It was concluded that measurements obtained with the DigiGraph™ Workstation should be interpreted with caution.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effects of cephalometric landmark validity on incisor angulationAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 1994
- Cephalometric errors: A comparison between repeat measurements and retaken radiographsAustralian Dental Journal, 1991
- Radiographic examinations of orthodontic educators and practitionersJournal of Dental Education, 1986
- Uncertainty in CephalometricsBritish Journal of Orthodontics, 1984
- Certain factors of aberration to be considered in clinical roentgenographic cephalometryAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 1952
- Variations in facial relationships: Their significance in treatment and prognosisAmerican Journal of Orthodontics, 1948
- On the growth pattern of the human head. From the third month to the eighth year of lifeJournal of Anatomy, 1941