Interobserver reproducibility of histological features in cutaneous malignant melanoma
Open Access
- 27 October 2005
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Clinical Pathology
- Vol. 58 (11) , 1194-1198
Abstract
Aims: To assess the interobserver reproducibility of certain histological features proposed for the diagnosis of melanoma. Methods: In a series of melanomas, 13 histological parameters were analysed: dimension > 6 mm, asymmetry, poor circumscription, irregular confluent nests, single melanocytes predominating, absence of maturation, suprabasal melanocytes, asymmetrical melanin, melanin in deep cells, cytological atypia, mitoses, dermal lymphocytic infiltrate, and necrosis. Results: The agreement (reproducibility) between the nine observers was excellent (κ > 0.75) for 10 of the 13 examined features (dimension > 6 mm, poor circumscription, irregular confluent nests, single melanocytes predominating, absence of maturation, suprabasal melanocytes, asymmetrical melanin, melanin in deep cells, mitoses, and necrosis). The agreement for asymmetry was very close to excellence (κ = 0.74), and that for cytological atypia (κ = 0.65) and dermal lymphocytic infiltrate (κ = 0.47) was slightly lower, but in the fair to good agreement range. The κ values obtained by comparison with the majority diagnosis were generally high (⩾ 0.85); the mean value of κ was lower (0.70) for only one parameter (dermal lymphocytic infiltrate). Conclusions: The parameters investigated showed an overall good reproducibility.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Histological features used in the diagnosis of melanoma are frequently found in benign melanocytic naeviJournal of Clinical Pathology, 2005
- Interobserver Reproducibility of Histopathologic Prognostic Variables in Primary Cutaneous MelanomasAmerican Journal of Surgical Pathology, 2003
- Under the microscope: doctors, lawyers, and melanocytic neoplasmsJournal of Cutaneous Pathology, 2003
- Silhouette symmetry: an unsupportable histologic criterion for distinguishing Spitz nevi and compound nevi from malignant melanoma.1997
- The evaluation of diagnostic and prognostic criteria and the terminology of thin cutaneous malignant melanoma by the CRC Melanoma Pathology PanelHistopathology, 1996
- Discordance in the histopathologic diagnosis of melanoma and melanocytic nevi between expert pathologistsHuman Pathology, 1996
- Interobserver variability on the histopathologic diagnosis of cutaneous melanoma and other pigmented skin lesions.Journal of Clinical Oncology, 1996
- Observer Variation in Histological Classification of Cutaneous Malignant MelanomaScandinavian Journal of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery and Hand Surgery, 1995
- Validity of the histopathological criteria used for diagnosing dysplastic naeviEuropean Journal of Cancer, 1993
- Histologic criteria for the diagnosis of superficial spreading malignant melanoma: Formulated on the basis of proven metastatic lesionsCancer, 1976