Using phosphate amendments to reduce bioaccessible Pb in contaminated soils: A meta-analysis
Open Access
- 7 November 2022
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Soil Science
- Vol. 2, 1-14
Abstract
Measuring the reduction of in vitro bioaccessible (IVBA) Pb from the addition of phosphate amendments has been researched for more than 20 years. A range of effects have been observed from increases in IVBA Pb to almost 100% reduction. This study determined the mean change in IVBA Pb as a fraction of total Pb (AC) and relative to the IVBA Pb of the control soil (RC) with a random effects meta-analysis. Forty-four studies that investigated the ability of inorganic phosphate amendments to reduce IVBA Pb were identified through 5 databases. These studies were split into 3 groups: primary, secondary, and EPA Method 1340 based on selection criteria, with the primary group being utilized for subgroup analysis and meta-regression. The mean AC was approximately -12% and mean RC was approximately -25% for the primary and secondary groups. For the EPA Method 1340 group, the mean AC was -5% and mean RC was -8%. The results of subgroup analysis identified the phosphorous amendment applied and contamination source as having a significant effect on the AC and RC. Soluble amendments reduce bioaccessible Pb more than insoluble amendments and phosphoric acid is more effective than other phosphate amendments. Urban Pb contamination associated with legacy Pb-paint and tetraethyl Pb from gasoline showed lower reductions than other sources such as shooting ranges and smelting operations. Meta-regression identified high IVBA Pb in the control, low incubated soil pH, and high total Pb with the greater reductions in AC and RC. In order to facilitate comparisons across future remediation research, a set of minimum reported data should be included in published studies and researchers should use standardized in vitro bioaccessibility methods developed for P-treated soils. Additionally, a shared data repository should be created for soil remediation research to enhance available soil property information and better identify unique materials.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ohio State University
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Metal immobilization and phosphorus leaching after stabilization of pyrite ash contaminated soil by phosphate amendmentsJournal of Environmental Monitoring, 2012
- A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysisResearch Synthesis Methods, 2010
- Long-Term Risk Reduction of Lead-Contaminated Urban Soil by Phosphate TreatmentEnvironmental Engineering Science, 2009
- Immobilization of Zn, Cu, and Pb in contaminated soils using phosphate rock and phosphoric acidJournal of Hazardous Materials, 2009
- Decreasing Lead Bioaccessibility in Industrial and Firing Range Soils with Phosphate‐Based AmendmentsJournal of Environmental Quality, 2008
- CEBS Chemical Effects in Biological Systems: a public data repository integrating study design and toxicity data with microarray and proteomics dataNucleic Acids Research, 2007
- Field Test of In Situ Soil Amendments at the Tar Creek National Priorities List Superfund SiteJournal of Environmental Quality, 2007
- Application Methods Affect Phosphorus‐Induced Lead Immobilization from a Contaminated SoilJournal of Environmental Quality, 2007
- Estimation of Lead and Arsenic Bioavailability Using a Physiologically Based Extraction TestEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1996
- In Situ Formation of Lead Phosphates in Soils as a Method to Immobilize LeadEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1994