Mental health legislation should respect decision making capacity
Authors:
Abstract
Introduction The government is introducing new mental health legislation in England and Wales. Critics have argued for some time that the 1983 Mental Health Act is outmoded, unable to provide the flexibility required after changes in psychiatric practice and social attitudes towards mental illness. Case law has also shown that the act has to be changed to ensure compatibility with human rights legislation. A draft bill was published in September 2004,1 and, after a report by a cross-party scrutiny committee in March 2005,2 the government announced its intention to introduce a new bill in autumn 2005. Concerns have been raised, however, by both user and professional groups about both the Mental Health Act and the draft legislation. The most serious of these is the lack of respect for the autonomy of mentally ill people, which we believe strikes at the heart of the legislation's moral legitimacy.Keywords
This publication has 2 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risk, Response, and Mental Health Policy: Learning from the Experience of the United KingdomJournal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 2002
- Autonomy, Guardianship and Mental Disorder: One Problem, Two SolutionsThe Modern Law Review, 2002