The aim of Chapter 2 is to reconstruct the ways in which intellectual orthodoxies (old and new) have dealt with the populist phenomenon from the 1950s up until today. In other words, emphasis will be given to the manner in which the social sciences, especially historical and political analysis, have interpreted and assessed populism. What conceptual resources were enlisted, which criteria were activated and what sensibilities were energized in order to deal with the populist ‘scandal’? At the forefront of our inquiry will be a reflexive, critical evaluation of the attempts of the liberal-leaning mainstream (from Hofstadter to Müller, Mudde and Rovira Kaltwasser) to interpret the complex history presented in the previous chapter. What will also be registered is a slow process through which the current academic mainstream seems to be moving forward to adopt an increasingly reflexive problematic. Yet a more radical break may be needed.