Russia’s Arctic strategies of 2014 and 2021: Is continuity possible amid shifting priorities? (Part 1)
- 17 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by Kola Science Centre in Север и рынок: формирование экономического порядка
- Vol. 28 (1) , 7-25
Abstract
This article examines the transformation of strategic documents for the development of the Russian Arctic, focusing on their value and functional content. Ensuring balance, continuity, and comprehensiveness in the regulatory influence of Arctic macroregional strategic management is particularly relevant amid the ongoing transformation of institutional foundations. The primary aim of this study is to identify the specific nature of these transformations and assess the continuity of their core principles. The research analyzes the value and functional content of strategic development documents for the Russian Arctic Zone, using official strategic planning documents as its information base. The study employs semantic and content analysis methods, utilizing the analytical capabilities of the Discant (Vega) system, the SemSin parser, and the Stalker utility. To assess discrepancies in semantic content, the Bray-Curtis index is applied. A detailed comparative analysis is conducted on strategic and policy documents from the first (2008–2014) and second (2020–2021) waves of Arctic policy formulation. The study identifies primary and secondary transformations in the value-semantic and functional content of these documents, as well as aspects of their continuity in the broader framework of socio-economic development. A key feature of the transformations is the expansion of specific policy measures in priority areas, including "ensuring security," "government support for economic entities," and "attracting investments." Notably, there is a growing emphasis on "security" in both military and public contexts, reflected in both value frameworks and policy measures. However, in certain areas, discrepancies emerge between the evolution of value orientations and the dynamics of policy implementation. The scientific contribution of this study lies in its depth of analysis and the quality of its examination of the value-semantic dimension within the transformation of Arctic strategic documents. Its practical significance is evident in the improved analytical capabilities it provides for refining policy and strategic documents, ensuring a more comprehensive and systematic approach to regulatory interventions. Future research will focus on assessing the internal and dynamic consistency of strategic documents in terms of their goals, measures, and anticipated outcomes.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- How effective are WEEE policies in China? A strategy evaluation through a PMC-index model with content analysisEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2024
- A content analysis of urban forest management plans in Canada: Changes in social-ecological objectives over timeLandscape and Urban Planning, 2024
- Role of local governments and households in low-waste city transitionsEnvironmental Innovation and Societal Transitions, 2024
- Evaluation of the central and local power batteries recycling policies in China: A PMC-Index model approachJournal of Cleaner Production, 2023
- Pairing EU directives and their national implementing measures: A dataset for semantic searchComputer Law & Security Review, 2023
- Content analysis of Chinese cities’ Five-Year Plan transport policy documentsCase Studies on Transport Policy, 2023
- Analysis of Machine Learning Algorithms for Predicting the Suitable Career After High School2022
- Effects of stakeholder participation on the quality of bicycle infrastructure. A case of Rattanakosin bicycle lane, Bangkok, ThailandCase Studies on Transport Policy, 2021
- Toward a typology of government social media communication: Democratic goals, symbolic acts and self-presentationGovernment Information Quarterly, 2018
- A framework for interpreting social media interactions in the public sectorGovernment Information Quarterly, 2013