Abstract
This paper draws on the industrial relations experiences of Britain and New Zealand in periods when economic rationalism held the ascendancy in their national policy agendas. In so doing, it looks at the impact of deregulatory provisions contained in laws directed at controlling the organisation and activities of trade unions. The paper finds that legislative reforms aimed at controlling the behaviour of trade unions are less effective in industrial relations environments characterised by a history of voluntarism and strong trade union presence in the workplace; and conversely, that reforming legislation aimed at achieving these ends is likely to be more effective in environments marked by a history of strong state support for compulsory arbitration and where trade unions are organisationally weak in the workplace. In view of the ‘Second Wave’ industrial relations legislation currently being considered by the Howard Government, the implication of these findings for Australian trade unions suggests that they must improve existing levels of workplace organisation if they are to avoid the fate of their New Zealand counterparts.

This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit: