Tactile maps may be produced in a wide variety of ways and the literature is replete with examples and supporting documentation of each particular method's successful use. The objective of the research reported, was to compare the map use performance of representative methods of tactile map production. The four production methods chosen, were Thermoforming, Multi-textural, Letter Press Plate, and Microcapsule paper. A similar set of four maps representing different levels of complexity was prepared by each technique. Each subject worked with one map at each level of map complexity and with examples of each of the map production methods being compared. The questionnaire comprising both locational and route-finding questions was administered individually to each subject and the time taken to solve each question was recorded as the basis for comparing maps. An unstructured interview was also held to explore each subject's 'feelings' about the maps and their map preference. The results of the study show maps on microcapsule paper recording the fastest times (the best performance). This held not only for the subject group as a whole but also for the subsets of total and partial blindness and by sex. Further, most subjects preferred the microcapsule paper map. In contrast, Thermoformed maps recorded the longest times for correct answers and were not reviewed favourably by the subjects.