Re‐presenting women executives: valorization and devalorization in US business press
Author:
- 1 May 2002
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Women in Management Review
- Vol. 17 (3/4) , 104-119
Abstract
Perceived compatibility between requirements of managerial work and attributes of women is believed important to the advancement and success of women, and research demonstrates continued ambivalence about women executives. The question of how images of women executives are disseminated, reproducing or contesting negative characterizations, has received little attention. The research reported here focuses on US business press as a cultural carrier disseminating images of women executives. Critical discourse analysis examined 27 front page Wall Street Journal accounts of 22 women executives in the year following Carly Fiorina’s appointment to head Hewlett‐Packard; 20 front page accounts of 24 men executives were used as comparison. Prominently featured articles on women executives provide fractured images of women as executives: while some accounts are positive, other portrayals reinforce negative perceptions of women’s competence and likeability as executives and concerns about the social order. Similar issues are not raised in coverage of male executives. Author gender does not seem to affect the portrayal.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Managing Like a Man: Women and Men in Corporate ManagementContemporary Sociology: A Journal of Reviews, 1999
- CONTESTING VALUATION OF "THE FEMININE" ON THE OP-ED PAGES OF THE WALL STREET JOURNAL: ONE RESPONSE TO FONDAS' CHALLENGE.Academy of Management Proceedings, 1999
- Pretty Versus Powerful in the Sports PagesJournal of Sport and Social Issues, 1999
- A decade of corporate women: some progress in the boardroom,none in the executive suiteStrategic Management Journal, 1999
- Relational PracticeJournal of Management Inquiry, 1998
- MANAGEMENT FASHIONAcademy of Management Review, 1996
- Management FashionAcademy of Management Review, 1996
- Power, Sex and SystemsWomen in Management Review, 1994
- Voicing Seduction to Silence LeadershipOrganization Studies, 1991
- The Social Production of Technical Work: The Case of British Engineers.Administrative Science Quarterly, 1988