Validity, Responsibility, and Aporia
- 11 June 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Inquiry
- Vol. 16 (8) , 603-610
Abstract
In this article, the author problematizes external, objectified, oversimplified, and mechanical approaches to validity in qualitative research, which endorse simplistic and reductionist views of knowledge and data. Instead of promoting one generalizable definition or operational criteria for validity, the author’s “deconstructive validity work” addresses how validity can be framed in the context of researchers’ responsibility and decision making during the research process. More specifically, the author utilizes the concept of aporia to discuss researchers’ responsibilities in the face of impossible decisions when aiming for “valid” and trustworthy qualitative research practices. The author argues that qualitative researchers should reconsider the promotion of validity or validation practices that disable researchers’ responsibility. Alternatively, it could be illuminative to ask how impossible validity and ongoing puzzlement associated with the quality of qualitative research could influence current research practices and reporting.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learning From Our Differences: A Dialogue Across Perspectives on Quality in Education ResearchEducational Researcher, 2009
- Validity as intended: ‘bursting forth toward’ bridling in phenomenological researchInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 2009
- (In)finite responsibilityPhilosophy & Social Criticism, 2009
- Picturing ValidityQualitative Inquiry, 2008
- Validity and Validation in the Making in the Context of Qualitative ResearchQualitative Health Research, 2008
- Validity in qualitative research revisitedQualitative Research, 2006
- Paradigm proliferation as a good thing to think with: teaching research in education as a wild profusionInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 2006
- Aporias, responsibility, and the im/possibility of teaching multicultural educationEducational Theory, 2005
- The face of the other: Zapatismo, responsibility and the ethics of deconstructionSocial & Cultural Geography, 2004
- Fertile Obsession: Validity After PoststructuralismThe Sociological Quarterly, 1993