Same Governance, Different Day: Does Metropolitan Reorganization Make a Difference?
- 24 June 2004
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Review of Policy Research
- Vol. 21 (4) , 595-611
Abstract
This commentary focuses on three points related to the debate about urban governmental restructuring: existing conflicts in the literature regarding the outcomes of local government consolidation; insights about consolidation based on an assessment of the amalgamation of twelve municipal units creating the new city of Ottawa; and, a discussion of a variety of methodological and political factors that may well account for the continuing inconsistency in academic assessments of structural change in local government. One possible explanation for the latter conflict is that governmental reorganization does not really make things substantially different in terms of taxes and services, that is, those outcomes most directly experienced by the average citizen. Over the long term other forces, such as intergovernmental relations and the economy, will tend to negate most of the initial effects of change. While there are likely to be winners and losers related to power in government or regime, it will be argued that in large part, for most citizens, governmental reorganization produces the same governance on a different day.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- State Economies, Metropolitan Governance, and Urban-Suburban Economic DependenceUrban Affairs Review, 2000
- Metropolitan Government and Economic DevelopmentUrban Affairs Review, 1999
- Dimensions of Interjurisdictional CooperationJournal of the American Planning Association, 1997
- Political participation and city county consolidation: jacksonville-duval countyInternational Journal of Public Administration, 1995
- Organizing Local Agencies to Promote Economic DevelopmentThe American Review of Public Administration, 1991
- Governmental Fragmentation versus Consolidation: Five Public-Choice Myths about How to Create Informed, Involved, and Happy CitizensPublic Administration Review, 1989
- The Allocational and Distributional Impacts of Governmental ConsolidationUrban Affairs Review, 1977
- The Politics of Metropolitan ReformAdministration & Society, 1974
- Responsiveness and ConsolidationUrban Affairs Review, 1973
- The jacksonville storyNational Civic Review, 1970