Dealing with research misconduct in the United KingdomAn American perspective on research integrityConduct unbecoming—the MRC's approachAn editor's response to fraudstersDeception: difficulties and initiativesHonest advice from Denmark
Author:
Abstract
# Dealing with research misconduct in the United Kingdom {#article-title-2} After years of inactivity over the problem of research misconduct in the United Kingdom, there is now an enthusiasm and drive to do something. But how should medical fraud be tackled? Representatives from medical journals (both British and American), the Medical Research Council, a medical school and a medical charity, and a member of the Danish Committee on Medical Dishonesty give their views on this important topic. # An American perspective on research integrity {#article-title-3} Editorial by Smith News by White An allegation of scientific fraud can ruin the careers of both the accused and the accuser, divide faculties, bring a research institution's functions to a halt, provide a field day for the media, and, when the scientific establishment is unprepared, result in a loss of confidence in the entire research enterprise. Yet, despite repeated demonstrations that this is the case, scientists are still reluctant to face up to such an unpleasant problem. Three years ago, at a meeting on research misconduct held by the BMJ , I warned that many extremely embarrassing incidents at a variety of institutions would be required before anyone took any action in the United Kingdom. This seems to have been borne out. At a meeting organised by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) in London, I was depressed that so few seemed to have paid the slightest attention to the rich, well documented and instructive experience of the United States, where an energetic attempt to face up to the problem has been made. Such parochialism may doom the UK to repeat the many mistakes already made by others. To the American observer, the news from the UK about incidents of misconduct in research is, as baseball's greatest philosopher, Yogi Berra, remarked, “déjà vu all over again.” I began to be seriously concerned about the problem in 1979 when, as deputy editor of the … Correspondence to: Sir Cyril ChantlerKeywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preventing the need for whistleblowing: Practical advice for university administratorsScience and Engineering Ethics, 1998
- Research misconduct.Gut, 1997
- Improving the Scientific Misconduct Hearing Process1997
- The misconduct of redundant publication.Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases, 1996
- International recruitment highlights need to track scientific behaviourNature, 1996
- Time to face up to research misconductBMJ, 1996
- Accountability, Audit, and Reverence for the Publication Process1993
- Scientific misconduct. New definition, procedures, and office--perhaps a new leaf1993
- Misconduct in medical research: does it exist in Britain?BMJ, 1988
- Lessons from the Darsee AffairNew England Journal of Medicine, 1983