Market Structure Effects on Internal CO2 Pricing in Hydrogen and Methanol Power-to-X Hubs
Preprint
- 27 June 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Energy hubs integrating Power-to-X technologies require the efficient allocation of shared resources such as electricity, hydrogen, and captured CO2. When several independent firms operate within the same hub, however, the internal price of such commodities is shaped not only by technical scarcity but also by the underlying market structure. This paper investigates how internal CO2 prices and resource allocation differ between a centrally coordinated energy hub and a decentralised firm-level representation. The analysis builds on the EnerHub2X optimisation framework and applies it to the GreenLab Skive energy hub, where biogenic CO2 from biogas upgrading serves as feedstock for e-methanol production. A central planner formulation derives system-optimal dispatch and shadow prices for liquefied CO2, while a firm-level approach represents CO2 suppliers and demanders as independent profit-maximising actors coordinated through a Walrasian price-response mechanism. The results show that under central coordination, the internal value of CO2 is primarily driven by supply scarcity, averaging 78 EUR/t in the Baseline scenario and collapsing to 7 EUR/t under abundant supply. Under the firm-level representation, equilibrium CO2 prices rise to approximately 125 EUR/t while total system profit falls by 22-75% relative to the central planner benchmark, consistently across storage and revenue scenarios. Storage is further shown to shift role depending on market structure, improving temporal efficiency under coordination while enabling intertemporal supply withholding under decentralisation. These results indicate that decentralised price formation can produce internally consistent prices that nevertheless deviate from system-optimal resource allocation, highlighting the need for explicit governance mechanisms for internally traded commodities in multi-actor energy hubs.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Renewable hydrogen and ammonia production: Location-specific considerations and competitive market dynamics in EuropeApplied Energy, 2025
- Feasibility of integrating excess heat from power-to-methanol: Case study of a Danish district heating networkApplied Energy, 2025
- Utilization of excess heat in future Power-to-X energy hubs through sector-couplingApplied Energy, 2024
- Optimal operation of a multi-generation district energy hub based on electrical, heating, and cooling demands and hydrogen productionApplied Energy, 2022
- Validation of European-scale simulated wind speed and wind generation time seriesApplied Energy, 2022
- Optimal operation of the energy hubs in the islanded multi-carrier energy system using Cournot modelApplied Thermal Engineering, 2021
- Modelling of renewable gas and renewable liquid fuels in future integrated energy systemsApplied Energy, 2020
- Dynamic pricing for decentralized energy trading in micro-gridsApplied Energy, 2018
- Methanol synthesis using captured CO2 as raw material: Techno-economic and environmental assessmentApplied Energy, 2016
- Optimal electrical and thermal energy management of a residential energy hub, integrating demand response and energy storage systemEnergy and Buildings, 2015