An inconvenient comparison: Climate change through the lens of the Holocaust
Author:
- 23 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Memory Studies
Abstract
This article examines how Holocaust memory shapes contemporary representations of climate change. Despite the climate crisis being unprecedented in human history, its cultural imagination often draws on historical calamities such as the Holocaust, nuclear annihilation, and colonial destruction. Employing the concepts of postmemory, multidirectional memory, and anticipatory memory, together with the notion of an ethics of comparison, the article explores how narratives of genocide serve as mnemonic templates for understanding environmental collapse while also assessing the ethical stakes of such analogies. It analyses public debates, academic discourse, and climate fiction, revealing how Holocaust comparisons function as rhetorical devices that mediate future-oriented anxieties and heighten the urgency of climate action. While these analogies are contentious and ethically fraught, risking trivialisation or historical distortion, they also mobilise the affective and political force of memory to confront the enormity of the climate crisis. Finally, the article turns to the genocide–ecocide nexus, arguing for an expanded framework of multidirectional eco-memory that acknowledges the entangled vulnerabilities of human and non-human life.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Genocide/ecocide: culture, public debate, languageHolocaust Studies, 2024
- ‘Never right to make comparisons’? Holocaust memory, climate crisis, and the debate over appropriate discourseHolocaust Studies, 2024
- Ecologies of violence: Cultural memory (studies) and the genocide–ecocide nexusMemory Studies, 2023
- The Climate Emergency: A Statement from Genocide Scholars on the Necessity for a Paradigm ShiftJournal of Genocide Research, 2021
- Quantifying national responsibility for climate breakdown: an equality-based attribution approach for carbon dioxide emissions in excess of the planetary boundaryThe Lancet Planetary Health, 2020
- Climate Change and the Art of Anticipatory MemoryParallax, 2017
- Traumatic Mirrorings: Holocaust and Colonial Trauma in Michael Chabon's the Final SolutionCriticism, 2011
- From Gaza to Warsaw: Mapping Multidirectional MemoryCriticism, 2011
- The Earth After Us2008
- Defusing the Global Warming TIME BOMBScientific American, 2004