Turkey's Rich Natural Heritage Under Assault
- 23 December 2011
- journal article
- Published by American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) in Science
- Vol. 334 (6063) , 1637-1639
Abstract
We read with sad agreement the editorial “Turkey and science academies” (30 September, p. [1801][1]), in which B. Alberts discusses the restructuring of Turkey's Academy of Sciences (TÜBA) in order to give the government direct control over it. In addition to destroying TÜBA's identity as an independent science academy, this remarkable decision was made without explanation or any public debate. As ecologists and conservation biologists working in Turkey, we have witnessed a similar level of increasing arbitrariness in environmental policy, where economic development has trumped all other concerns ([ 1 ][2]–[ 4 ][3]). Turkey hosts more than 3000 endemic plant species, has high diversity of other taxa, and is almost entirely covered by three of the world's 34 biodiversity hotspots ([ 1 ][2]). Yet, Turkey's environmental laws and conservation efforts are eroding, not improving ([ 1 ][2]–[ 4 ][3]). This has precipitated a conservation crisis that has accelerated over the past decade ([ 1 ][2]). This crisis has been exacerbated by legislative developments that may leave Turkey with a nature conservation legal framework that is weakened and severely out of line with globally accepted principles ([ 1 ][2]–[ 8 ][4]). This situation is further worsened by increasing bureaucratic complexity, fragmentation, overlap, and conflict among government departments responsible for nature conservation, combined with limited communication, cooperation, and coordination among them ([ 2 ][5]). Protected Area jurisprudence, long the cornerstone of effective resource conservation, has declined especially rapidly over the past two years as a result of legal decisions that have enabled: 1. (i) Mining in wildlife refuges (June 2010) ([ 5 ][6]). 2. (ii) Exclusion of riparian and coastal areas from wetland conservation zoning, which removed a major environmental control mechanism to dam construction and tourism development (August 2010) ([ 6 ][7]). 3. (iii) Construction of dams and other energy projects in Protected Areas (December 2010) ([ 7 ][8]), with the ultimate goal of doubling Turkey's dams and hydroelectric power plants to 4000 by 2023 ([ 1 ][2], [ 7 ][8]). 4. (iv) Redefining of terms such as “balance between use and conservation,” common good,” and “sustainable use” in the misleadingly named Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Law , while minimizing civil society involvement in its drafting (March 2011) ([ 2 ][5], [ 7 ][8], [ 8 ][4]), in order to enable development in Protected Areas. 5. (v) Zoning 473,419 hectares of 2/B lands deforested before 1981 to convert them to other uses and/or sell them to developers, instead of protecting and restoring these areas, which often include biodiverse and important habitats such as maquis, phrygana , and successional forests (July 2011) ([ 1 ][2], [ 9 ][9]). 6. (vi) Termination of the independent and local Natural and Cultural Assets Conservation Committees, formerly the sole determinants of officially protected “Natural Sites.” Instead, this decision-making process has been centralized under the new Ministry of Environment and Urbanization, and the civil society has been excluded ([ 2 ][5], [ 7 ][8]). Recent legislation (August 2011) ([ 1 ][2], [ 2 ][5]) puts the 1261 strictly protected Natural Sites created since 1923 under review. We anticipate that many of these Protected Areas, some of which now impede dam construction and other development projects, will not survive what will likely be a biased review process ([ 3 ][10], [ 7 ][8], [ 8 ][4]). The 2010 Yale Environmental Performance Index ([ 10 ][11]) ranked Turkey 140th out of 163 countries in biodiversity and habitat conservation. Even the meager 1.2% of Turkish lands that are “strictly” protected [IUCN categories I and II ([ 11 ][12])] have come under threat ([ 1 ][2]). Analogous to the midnight overhauling of TÜBA without consultation or debate, it has become routine to pass legislation rapidly and secretively, and to circumvent or corrupt the Environmental Impact Assessment process, in order to remove any debate or legal obstacles to dams, roads, and other developments. Increasingly, such projects are planned in formerly Protected Areas to the detriment of local peoples as well as biodiversity ([ 4 ][3], [ 7 ][8]). July 2011 division of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry into the Ministry of Environment and Urbanization and the Ministry of Forestry and Water Affairs (led by the former heads of public housing and water affairs agencies, respectively) has institutionalized the emphasis placed on urban development and dam construction at the expense of the environment ([ 12 ][13]) and of the rights of the affected people ([ 4 ][3], [ 7 ][8]). Combined with the rise in Turkey's greenhouse gas emissions from 170 to 370 million tons between 1990 and 2009, this growing destruction of natural areas will further increase Turkey's contribution to global climate change ([ 13 ][14]). These issues have rarely been discussed in international forums, although this is changing ([ 1 ][2], [ 4 ][3], [ 7 ][8], [ 12 ][13]). Nevertheless, the international scientific community remains largely unaware of both Turkey's unique biodiversity and its impending peril. As the international scientific community reacts to the arbitrary government takeover of Turkey's scientific institutions, we hope that it will realize that the government is disregarding not only the country's scientists, but also Turkey's rich natural heritage and the people who depend on it. 1. [↵][15] 1. Ç. H. Şekercioğlu 2. et al ., Biol. Conserv. 144, 2752 (2011). [OpenUrl][16][CrossRef][17][Web of Science][18] 2. [↵][19] Nature Law Watch Initiative, “Letter to the ministries” (2011); [www.tabiatkanunu.wordpress.com/english/][20]. 3. [↵][21] Nature Law Watch Initiative, “Final blow to the nature of Turkey:...Keywords
This publication has 1 reference indexed in Scilit:
- Turkey’s globally important biodiversity in crisisBiological Conservation, 2011