The Effect of Bad‐Faith Laws on First‐Party Insurance Claims Decisions
Authors:
- Mark J. BrowneMBMark J. Browne
- Ellen S. PryorEPEllen S. Pryor
- Bob PuelzBPBob Puelz
- 1 June 2004
- journal article
- Published by University of Chicago Press in The Journal of Legal Studies
- Vol. 33 (2) , 355-390
Abstract
This study sets forth the legal distinctions among bad-faith laws and provides a theoretical foundation for our hypotheses that bad-faith laws affect both economic and noneconomic damage amounts. We use data that include information about uninsured and underinsured “closed claims”—that is, claims that have either been settled or been paid or closed after trial—under automobile policies from over 60 insurance companies in 38 jurisdictions in 1992. While controlling for multiple other factors that are expected to be associated with the size of settlement payments, we exploit differences in state laws that govern insurer bad faith to examine empirically whether bad-faith remedies affect the size of settlement payments and the allocation of settlement payments between economic and noneconomic damages. We find a positive correlation between the existence of a bad-faith remedy and higher settlement payments. This correlation exists for both economic and noneconomic damages.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Incentives to Settle Under Joint and Several Liability: An Empirical Analysis of Superfund LitigationThe Journal of Legal Studies, 2000
- THE EFFECT OF STATE TORT REFORMS ON CLAIM FILINGSRisk Management and Insurance Review, 1997
- "Bad Faith" Breach of Contract by First-Party InsurersThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1996
- Statutory Rules, Attorney Involvement, and Automobile Liability ClaimsJournal of Risk and Insurance, 1996
- Multidefendant Settlements: The Impact of Joint and Several LiabilityThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1994
- The effect of 1980s tort reform legislation on general liability and medical malpractice insuranceJournal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1993
- Do We Really Know Anything about the Behavior of the Tort Litigation System. And Why Not?University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1992
- The Duty to SettleVirginia Law Review, 1990
- The Performance of Liability Insurance in States with Different Products-Liability StatutesThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1990
- Liability Insurance and Responsibility for SettlementHarvard Law Review, 1954