Evolving paradigms in coastal spatial planning: A six-decade review of land–sea integration and lessons for Indonesia

Authors:

Abstract
This review traces the evolution of integrated approaches to coastal and marine planning from 1968 to 2025 and examines their implications for contemporary land–sea integration. Using a longitudinal narrative review of 315 Scopus-indexed articles, the study examines three prominent families of practice: Integrated Coastal Management (ICM), Marine Spatial Planning (MSP), and the more recent Integrated Land–Sea (ILS) approaches. Five analytical stages structure the assessment: temporal evolution, global spatial distribution, comparative country experiences, effectiveness themes, and a cross-cutting SWOT perspective. The results show a clear shift from early, largely sectoral ICM initiatives toward more spatially explicit, ecosystem-based, and multi-level governance frameworks. MSP emerges as a response to intensifying competition for marine space, while ILS extends this logic by explicitly connecting watersheds, coasts, and offshore areas through land–sea interaction thinking. Regionally, North America and Europe dominate the literature. However, important contributions also come from Asia, Australia, Africa, and South America, with China, Norway, and Australia standing out as long-term laboratories of integrative practice. Across contexts, adequate arrangements combine strong legal mandates, coherent institutions, reliable spatial data, and meaningful stakeholder participation; in contrast, fragmented regulations, overlapping mandates, and capacity gaps continue to limit implementation, particularly in developing and archipelagic states. For Indonesia, the review highlights persistent disconnections between terrestrial spatial plans and marine zoning. It underscores the need for more explicit integration rules, national indicators, and GIS-based planning-support systems to align provincial RTRW with marine plans and climate-risk zoning. Overall, the study offers a multi-dimensional framework for comparing ICM, MSP, and ILS, and proposes policy pathways to strengthen land–sea integration for resilient and sustainable coastal development.

This publication has 260 references indexed in Scilit: