Problems of exclusionary research criteria: The case against the “usable knowledge” litmus test for social justice communication research
- 1 December 2003
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Communication Studies
- Vol. 54 (4) , 438-450
Abstract
In 1996 five Loyola University faculty members proposed limiting the term “social justice communication research” exclusively to studies whose designs focused on “usable knowledge.” For them, that criterion necessitates that a legitimate social justice research project entail immediate action recommendations and direct researcher intervention in the interests of immediate study participants. This essay contends that such a litmus test restricts acceptable research to short‐term case studies aimed at immediately measurable outcomes produced by the researcher him‐ or herself, qualities that do not necessarily match the complex nature of problems of social in(justice) or exclusively yield the type of research outcomes that most powerfully address such problems. Widespread acceptance of their criterion: 1) limits scholarly influence to those few sites of struggle where a researcher's location and finite schedule allow extended personal engagement; 2) encourages counter‐productive dependence by lay social justice advocates on Communication researchers; 3) works against discovering and integrating broader, long‐term systemic solutions or effectively empowering advocates in other social justice struggles; 4) discourages the innovation of “the scholarship of discovery” with respect to social (in)justice issues in favor of the safer, predictable strategies of responsible “scholarship of application” (and vice versa) by necessitating the combination of conflicting objectives in a single scholarly project; and 5) promotes dysfunctional isolation and territoriality within the Communication discipline.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- On putting social justice in the discipline of communication and putting enriched concepts of communication in social justice research and practiceJournal of Applied Communication Research, 1998
- Lincoln and Douglas meet the abolitionist David Walker as prisoners debate slavery: Empowering education, applied communication, and social justiceJournal of Applied Communication Research, 1998
- African‐Americans and higher education: An exigence in need of applied communicationJournal of Applied Communication Research, 1998
- Communication and social justice research: Truth, justice, and the applied communication wayJournal of Applied Communication Research, 1998
- Navigating between Scylla and Charybdis: Continuing the dialogue on communication and social justiceCommunication Studies, 1996
- Notes on communication education and social justiceCommunication Studies, 1996
- Social justice research: Alive and well in the field of communicationCommunication Studies, 1996
- Looking for justice in all the wrong places: On a communication approach to social justiceCommunication Studies, 1996
- Judges’ influence on trial outcomes and jurors’ experiences of justice: Reinscribing existing hierarchies through the sanctuary trialJournal of Applied Communication Research, 1994