Accuracy of unmodified Stokes’ integration in the R-C-R procedure for geoid computation
Authors:
- Zahra IsmailZIZahra Ismail
- Olivier JametOJOlivier Jamet
- 1 January 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Journal of Applied Geodesy
- Vol. 9 (2) , 112-122
Abstract
Geoid determinations by the Remove-Compute-Restore (R-C-R) technique involves the application of Stokes’ integral on reduced gravity anomalies. Numerical Stokes’ integration produces an error depending on the choice of the integration radius, grid resolution and Stokes’ kernel function.In this work, we aim to evaluate the accuracy of Stokes’ integral through a study on synthetic gravitational signals derived from EGM2008 on three different landscape areas with respect to the size of the integration domain and the resolution of the anomaly grid. The influence of the integration radius was studied earlier by several authors. Using real data, they found that the choice of relatively small radii (less than 1°) enables to reach an optimal accuracy. We observe a general behaviour coherent with these earlier studies. On the other hand, we notice that increasing the integration radius up to 2° or 2.5° might bring significantly better results. We note that, unlike the smallest radius corresponding to a local minimum of the error curve, the optimal radius in the range 0° to 6° depends on the terrain characteristics. We also find that the high frequencies, from degree 600, improve continuously with the integration radius in both semi-mountainous and mountain areas.Finally, we note that the relative error of the computed geoid heights depends weakly on the anomaly spherical harmonic degree in the range from degree 200 to 2000. It remains greater than 10 % for any integration radii up to 6°. This result tends to prove that a one centimetre accuracy cannot be reached in semi-mountainous and mountainous regions with the unmodified Stokes’ kernel.Keywords
This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit:
- A strategy towards an EGM08-based Fennoscandian geoid modelJournal of Applied Geophysics, 2012
- Comparison of remove-compute-restore and least squares modification of Stokes' formula techniques to quasi-geoid determination over the Auvergne test areaJournal of Geodetic Science, 2012
- Modelling the fine-structure of the geoid: Methods, data requirements and some resultsSurveys in Geophysics, 1993
- Tests on the recovery of precise geoid height differences from gravimetryJournal of Geophysical Research, 1988
- Data requirements for determining precise relative geoid heights from gravimetryJournal of Geophysical Research, 1986