Minimizing opportunity costs to aquatic connectivity restoration while controlling an invasive species
- 8 March 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 32 (4) , 894-904
Abstract
Controlling invasive species is critical for conservation but can have unintended consequences for native species and divert resources away from other efforts. This dilemma occurs on a grand scale in the North American Great Lakes, where dams and culverts block tributary access to habitat of desirable fish species and are a lynchpin of long‐standing efforts to limit ecological damage inflicted by the invasive, parasitic sea lamprey ( Petromyzon marinus ). Habitat restoration and sea‐lamprey control create conflicting goals for managing aging infrastructure. We used optimization to minimize opportunity costs of habitat gains for 37 desirable migratory fishes that arose from restricting sea lamprey access (0–25% increase) when selecting barriers for removal under a limited budget (US$1–105 million). Imposing limits on sea lamprey habitat reduced gains in tributary access for desirable species by 15–50% relative to an unconstrained scenario. Additional investment to offset the effect of limiting sea‐lamprey access resulted in high opportunity costs for 30 of 37 species (e.g., an additional US$20–80 million for lake sturgeon [ Acipenser fulvescens ]) and often required ≥5% increase in sea‐lamprey access to identify barrier‐removal solutions adhering to the budget and limiting access. Narrowly distributed species exhibited the highest opportunity costs but benefited more at less cost when small increases in sea‐lamprey access were allowed. Our results illustrate the value of optimization in limiting opportunity costs when balancing invasion control against restoration benefits for diverse desirable species. Such trade‐off analyses are essential to the restoration of connectivity within fragmented rivers without unleashing invaders.Keywords
Funding Information
- Great Lakes Fishery Trust
- David and Lucile Packard Foundation
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fish movement and migration studies in the Laurentian Great Lakes: Research trends and knowledge gapsJournal of Great Lakes Research, 2011
- The Effects of the Stronach Dam Removal on Fish in the Pine River, Manistee County, MichiganTransactions of the American Fisheries Society, 2010
- Hydrologic impacts of projected future climate change in the Lake Michigan regionJournal of Great Lakes Research, 2010
- An Operating Model for the Integrated Pest Management of Great Lakes Sea LampreysThe Open Fish Science Journal, 2009
- Fencing for conservation: Restriction of evolutionary potential or a riposte to threatening processes?Biological Conservation, 2009
- Effects of low-head barriers on stream fishes: taxonomic affiliations and morphological correlates of sensitive speciesCanadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2006
- Optimizing the removal of small fish passage barriersEnvironmental Modeling & Assessment, 2005
- Sea Lamprey Abundance and Management in Lake Superior, 1957 to 1999Journal of Great Lakes Research, 2003
- History of and Advances in Barriers as an Alternative Method to Suppress Sea Lampreys in the Great LakesJournal of Great Lakes Research, 2003
- Compensatory Mechanisms in Great Lakes Sea Lamprey Populations: Implications for Alternative Control StrategiesJournal of Great Lakes Research, 2003