Abstract
We evaluate the use of the modified profile likelihood in regression analysis of the log odds ratio in a set of 2 x 2 tables. It has been shown that unconditional maximum likelihood inference is biased when there are many nuisance parameters, while exact conditional maximum likelihood inference, though accurate, can be infeasible in large problems. The modified profile likelihood provides an estimator of the odds ratio that closely approximates the exact conditional maximum likelihood estimator. It is demonstrated that in the situation where the number of tables increases to infinity the corrected maximum modified profile likelihood estimator is consistent to first order while the unconditional maximum likelihood estimator is known to be badly inconsistent. Numerical work demonstrates that the asymptotic bias of the maximum modified profile likelihood estimator of a common odds ratio is negligible for odds ratios less than 5.