The impact of mental health evidence on support for capital punishment: are defendants labeled psychopathic considered more deserving of death?
Authors:
- John F. EdensJEJohn F. Edens
- Lori H. ColwellLCLori H. Colwell
- Donna M. DesforgesDDDonna M. Desforges
- Krissie FernandezKFKrissie Fernandez
- 16 September 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Behavioral Sciences & the Law
- Vol. 23 (5) , 603-625
Abstract
Controversy surrounds the use of the Hare Psychopathy Checklist—Revised (Hare, 1991, 2003) in capital murder cases, where it has been introduced to support prosecution claims that a defendant represents a “continuing threat to society”. Although widely presumed to have a prejudicial impact (e.g., American Psychological Association, 2004), little is known about how the lay public reacts to data derived from ostensibly stigmatizing assessment instruments such as the PCL‐R. The present study examined the effect of psychopathy data on layperson attitudes by having 203 undergraduates review a capital murder case where the results of the defendant's psychological evaluation were experimentally manipulated. When expert testimony described the defendant as psychopathic, a much larger percentage of participants supported a death sentence (60%) than when testimony indicated that he was psychotic (30%) or not mentally disordered (38%). Interestingly, participant ratings of how psychopathic they perceived the defendant to be—regardless of the testimony condition to which they had been assigned—also predicted support for a death sentence. Given the limited probative value of the PCL‐R in capital cases and the prejudicial nature of the effects noted in this study, we recommend that forensic examiners avoid using it in these trials. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Predictions of Future Dangerousness in Capital Murder Trials: Is It Time to "Disinvent the Wheel?"Law and Human Behavior, 2005
- Juror decision‐making in a mock sexually violent predator trial: gender differences in the impact of divergent types of expert testimonyBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2003
- The effects of clinical and scientific expert testimony on juror decision making in capital sentencing.Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2001
- Don't Confuse me with the FactsCriminal Justice and Behavior, 1999
- Clarifying life and death matters: An analysis of instructional comprehension and penalty phase closing arguments.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- Illuminations and shadows from jury simulations.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- Jurors' comprehension of sentencing instructions: A test of the death penalty process in TennesseeJustice Quarterly, 1997
- Comprehension of judges' instructions in the penalty phase of a capital trial: Focus on mitigating circumstances.Law and Human Behavior, 1992
- Jury decision making in the capital penalty phase: Legal assumptions, empirical findings, and a research agenda.Law and Human Behavior, 1992
- Psychopathy and violent recidivism.Law and Human Behavior, 1991