Comparisons between NaD 2 (589 nm), Fe (372 and 386 nm), and He( 3 S) (1083 nm) laser-induced fluorescence lidars: influence of the Hanle effect and single-photon measurement uncertainty
Authors:
- Chiao-Yao SheCSChiao-Yao She
- David A. KruegerDKDavid A. Krueger
- 13 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by Optica Publishing Group in Applied Optics
- Vol. 64 (33) , 10004-10016
Abstract
Inthis paper, we systematically compare the bias caused by ignoring the Hanle effect in retrieving atmospheric density N , temperature T , and line-of-sight wind V by four laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) lidars. Under a typical condition in the mesopause ( T =200K, V =0ms −1 ) for NaD 2 (589 nm), Fe (372 nm), and Fe (386 nm) and in the thermosphere ( T =1000K, V =0ms −1 ) for He( 3 S) (1083 nm) lidars, we find an overestimate in N of 8.3%, 8.7%, 16%, and 17%, respectively. Though no bias exists in the retrieved T and V for the two Fe lidars, the bias of ignoring the Hanle effect is (−0.28K, 0.70 m/s) for NaD 2 (589 nm) lidar and (−19.6K, −24.6m/s) for He( 3 S) (1083 nm) lidar. We also evaluated the associated single-photon measurement uncertainties ( δ T 1 S and δ V 1 S ) and find them to be (506 K, 429 m/s), (451 K, 252 m/s), (494 K, 247 m/s), and (3847 K, 2560 m/s), respectively. When divided by the received signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of a measurement, these quantities are related to the corresponding measurement uncertainties ( δ T air and δ V air ) as (2 δ T 1 S SNR> δ T air ≥ δ T 1 S SNR and 2 δ V 1 S SNR> δ V air ≥ δ V 1 S SNR), where the equality holds when the received background is zero.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Metastable Helium Lidar for Thermosphere and Lower Exosphere Measurements: Instrument Description and Initial ResultsSpace Weather, 2024
- Measurements of metastable helium in Earth’s atmosphere by resonance lidarNature Communications, 2022
- Atmospheric Lidar Fundamentals2022
- Isotope shifts and hyperfine structure of the372-nm resonance linePhysical Review A, 2009
- Metal fluorescence lidar (light detection and ranging) and the middle atmosphereContemporary Physics, 2003
- The mesopause altitude: Only two distinctive levels worldwide?Geophysical Research Letters, 1996
- Two‐frequency Lidar technique for mesospheric Na temperature measurementsGeophysical Research Letters, 1990
- Mesopause temperatures derived from probing the hyperfine structure of the D2 resonance line of sodium by lidarJournal of Atmospheric and Terrestrial Physics, 1985
- High-resolution spectroscopy with and frequency stabilization of a cw dye laserApplied Physics A, 1973
- ber magnetische Beeinflussung der Polarisation der ResonanzfluoreszenzThe European Physical Journal A, 1924