God’s Technicians: Religious Jurists and the Usury Ban in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam
Author:
- 26 September 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of Chicago Press in European Journal of Sociology
- Vol. 57 (2) , 207-257
Abstract
At the heart of the $2 trillion Islamic-finance industry is a ban on interest. But why is there only anIslamicban on interest today? After all, for over a millennium, interest was also gravely sinful in Judaism and Christianity. While scholars have addressed the evolution of Jewish, Christian, and Islamic economic morality in isolation, very few since Weber have tackled the interest question directly and comparatively.I argue that the fate of the religious interest ban has always depended on the fate of religious jurists. When religious jurists are absent, no systematic interest ban emerges. When religious jurists emerge as technical experts, the interest ban appears and thrives. And when religious jurists come under attack or lose their traditional role in society, the interest ban withers and dies.To conclude, I call for a reconstruction of Weber’s theory of religion and economic morality that dissolves the tradition-modernity binary.Keywords
This publication has 89 references indexed in Scilit:
- Commodity futures: An Islamic legal analysisThunderbird International Business Review, 2007
- In Hock: Pawning in Early AmericaJournal of the Early Republic, 2007
- “A Kingdom of Priests”: The Democratization of the Priesthood in the Literature of Second Temple JudaismThe Journal of Jewish Thought and Philosophy, 1997
- Deontic and Epistemic Authority in Roman Catholic Ethics: The Case of Richard McCormickChristian bioethics: Non-Ecumenical Studies in Medical Morality, 1996
- THE ECONOMIC ETHICS OF RUSSIAN-ORTHODOX CHRISTIANITY: PART II - RUSSIAN OLD BELIEVERS AND SECTSInternational Sociology, 1989
- THE ECONOMIC ETHICS OF RUSSIAN-ORTHODOX CHRISTIANITY: PART IInternational Sociology, 1989
- Outline of a Theory of PracticeASA Review of Books, 1980
- ISLAM AND WEBER: RODINSON ON THE IMPLICATIONS OF RELIGION FOR CAPITALIST DEVELOPMENTThe Developing Economies, 1977
- THE LAWS ON INTEREST IN THE OLD TESTAMENTThe Journal of Theological Studies, 1953
- The Valuation of Property in the Roman LawHarvard Law Review, 1921