Is There a “Consensus” on School Choice and Achievement?
Authors:
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Educational Policy
- Vol. 23 (1) , 161-193
Abstract
A number of school choice advocates claim that there is a research consensus indicating that vouchers for private schools lead to higher academic achievement. The authors review and critique these local studies of voucher programs, contrasting them with findings from larger-scale analyses of nationally representative samples of public and private schools, which illuminate patterns that appear to undercut the assumption of superior private school performance that is a premise of voucher programs. The authors note limitations inherent in different methodological approaches to this question, focusing on the shortcomings of randomization as an exclusive “gold standard” for research on the issue of achievement in school choice plans. The concluding discussion reconsiders the question of a consensus, highlighting the emerging research environment that bypasses traditional review processes and emphasizes instead the promotion of ideas to support policy agendas.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Public‐Private Differences in Achievement among Kindergarten Students: Differences in Learning Opportunities and Student OutcomesAmerican Journal of Education, 2006
- School Sector and Academic Achievement: A Multilevel Analysis of NAEP Mathematics DataAmerican Educational Research Journal, 2006
- Another Look at the New York City School Voucher ExperimentAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 2004
- Inefficiency, Subsample Selection Bias, and NonrobustnessAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 2004
- Further Evidence on the Effects of Catholic Secondary SchoolingBrookings-Wharton Papers on Urban Affairs, 2000
- The Milwaukee Voucher ExperimentEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 1998
- Student Achievement in Public Magnet, Public Comprehensive, and Private City High SchoolsEducational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 1996
- Catholic-School Effects on Academic Achievement: New Evidence from the High School and Beyond Follow-Up StudySociology of Education, 1985
- School Sector and Cognitive Performance: When is a Little a Little?Sociology of Education, 1985
- The Causal Analysis of Cognitive Outcomes in the Coleman, Hoffer and Kilgore ReportSociology of Education, 1982