A prospective trial of a new policy eliminating signed consent for do not resuscitate orders
- 1 December 2006
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of General Internal Medicine
- Vol. 21 (12) , 1261-1268
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Some institutions require patients and families to give signed consent for Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) orders, especially in New York State. As this may be a barrier to discussions about DNR orders, we changed a signed consent policy to a witnessed verbal consent policy, simplified and modified the DNR order forms, and educated the staff at 1 hospital, comparing the effects with an affiliated hospital where the policy was not changed. DESIGN: Prospective natural experiment with intervention and comparison sites. SUBJECTS AND MEASUREMENTS: Pre- and postintervention, we surveyed house officers’ confidence and attitudes, reviewed charts to assess the number of concurrent care concerns (CCCs) addressed per DNR order (e.g., limits on intubation or blood products or need for hospice), and at the intervention hospital, measured the stress levels of surrogates consenting for DNR orders using the Horowitz Impact of Event Scale. We also surveyed staff perceptions about the policy following the change. RESULTS: At the intervention hospital, the percentage of house officers reporting low confidence in their ability to obtain consent for DNR orders declined postintervention (24% to 7%,P=.002), while there was no significant change at the comparison hospital (20% vs 15%,P=.45). Among intervention hospital house officers, there were declines in percent reporting difficulty talking to patients and families about DNR orders, but no significant changes at the comparison hospital. At the intervention hospital, the mean number of CCCs/DNR order increased (1.0 pre to 4.2 post,P<.001), but did not change significantly (1.2 pre to 1.4 post) at the comparison hospital. The mean total stress score for intervention hospital surrogates declined postintervention (23.6 to 17.3,P=.02), indicating lower stress. House officers (98%), attendings (59%), and nurses (79%) thought the new policy was better for families. CONCLUSIONS: The policy change was well received and associated with improved house officer attitudes, more attention to patients’ concurrent care concerns, and decreased surrogate stress. The results suggest that DNR orders can be made simpler and clearer, and raise questions about policies requiring signed consent for DNR orders.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do-not-resuscitate order after 25 years*Critical Care Medicine, 2003
- Factors Associated With the Time Nurses Spend at the Bedsides of Seriously Ill Patients With Poor PrognosesMedical Care, 2003
- Do the ward notes reflect the quality of end-of-life care?Journal of Medical Ethics, 1996
- The 1988 DNR Reforms: A Comparative Study of the Impact of the New York DNR Law and the Jcaho Accreditation Requirements1995
- The New York State Do-Not-Resuscitate Law: A Study of Public Policy-Making1995
- The quality of mercy. Caring for patients with 'do not resuscitate' ordersJAMA, 1992
- The APACHE III Prognostic SystemChest, 1991
- Cognitive research improves questionnaires.American Journal of Public Health, 1989
- Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change.Psychological Review, 1977
- Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change.Psychological Review, 1977