THE DIVERSITY–VALIDITY DILEMMA: BEYOND SELECTION—THE ROLE OF AFFIRMATIVE ACTION
- 6 February 2008
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Personnel Psychology
- Vol. 61 (1) , 173-193
Abstract
Several of the most valid predictors used to make employment decisions create a diversity–validity dilemma (Pyburn, Ployhart, & Kravitz, this issue, 2008). This diversity–validity dilemma can be resolved by (a) reducing adverse impact through a variety of technical steps (Ployhart & Holtz, this issue, 2008) or (b) using affirmative action to increase representation of the disadvantaged groups. This paper focuses on the second approach. The paper begins with a very brief review of the legal bases of affirmative action and a summary of the research on affirmative action attitudes. This is followed with reviews of research on the ongoing existence of workplace discrimination, the economic impact of affirmative action on target groups and organizations, and stigmatization of target group members by others and by target group members themselves. Most problems with affirmative action apply only or primarily to preference‐based forms, so nonpreferential approaches to affirmative action are recommended to increase the attraction, selection, inclusion, and retention of underrepresented group members.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- WHAT HAS RACE GOT TO DO WITH IT? UNRAVELING THE ROLE OF RACIOETHNICITY IN JOB SEEKERS' REACTIONS TO SITE VISITSPersonnel Psychology, 2006
- The Impact of Affirmative Action: Black Employment in Six Southern Cities*Social Science Quarterly, 2003
- AFFIRMATIVE ACTION ATTITUDES: EFFECTS OF RESPONDENT ETHNICITY, AAP STRENGTH, AND ANTICIPATED IMPACTS.Academy of Management Proceedings, 2002
- THE ASA FRAMEWORK: AN UPDATEPersonnel Psychology, 1995
- The Content of Our Categories: A Cognitive Bias Approach to Discrimination and Equal Employment OpportunityStanford Law Review, 1995
- Impact of Affirmative Action on Beneficiary Groups: Evidence From the 1990 General Social SurveyBasic and Applied Social Psychology, 1994
- Attributional Ambiguity of Affirmative ActionBasic and Applied Social Psychology, 1994
- Skirting the competence issue: Effects of sex-based preferential selection on task choices of women and men.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1991
- Intentionally favored, unintentionally harmed? Impact of sex-based preferential selection on self-perceptions and self-evaluations.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1987
- Experiments in Intergroup DiscriminationScientific American, 1970