Aggregation of Individual Rankings Through Fusion Functions: Criticism and Optimality Analysis
Authors:
- Humberto BustinceHumberto Bustince
- Benjamin BedregalBBBenjamin Bedregal
- Maria Jesus CampionMaria Jesus Campion
- Ivanosca da SilvaISIvanosca da Silva
- Javier FernandezJavier Fernandez
- Esteban IndurainEsteban Indurain
- Armajac Raventos-PujolARArmajac Raventos-Pujol
- Regivan H. N. SantiagoRSRegivan H. N. Santiago
- 9 December 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems
- Vol. 30 (3) , 638-648
Abstract
Throughout this paper, our main idea is to analyze from a theoretical and normative point of view different methods to aggregate individual rankings. To do so, first we introduce the concept of a general mean on an abstract set. This new concept conciliates the Social Choice where well-known impossibility results as the Arrovian ones are encountered and the Decision-Making approaches where the necessity of fusing rankings is unavoidable. Moreover it gives rise to a reasonable definition of the concept of a ranking fusion function that does indeed satisfy the axioms of a general mean. Then we will introduce some methods to build ranking fusion functions, paying a special attention to the use of score functions, and pointing out the equivalence between ranking and scoring. To conclude, we prove that any ranking fusion function introduces a partial order on rankings implemented on a finite set of alternatives. Therefore, this allows us to compare rankings and different methods of aggregation, so that in practice one should look for the maximal elements with respect to such orders defined on rankingsKeywords
Funding Information
- MINECO/AEI-FEDER, UE (ECO2015-65031-R, MTM2015-63608-P)
- MINECO/AEI-FEDER, UE (TIN2016-77356-P, PID2019-108392GB-I00)
- Brazilian National Council for Scientific and Technological Development CNPq (307781/2016-0)
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Using extension sets to aggregate partial rankings in a flexible settingApplied Mathematics and Computation, 2016
- Weighted Average Operators Generated by n-dimensional Overlaps and an Application in Decision2015
- Consensus in multi-expert decision making problems using penalty functions defined over a Cartesian product of latticesInformation Fusion, 2014
- Construction of interval-valued fuzzy preference relations from ignorance functions and fuzzy preference relations. Application to decision makingKnowledge-Based Systems, 2013
- An alternative to fuzzy methods in decision-making problemsExpert Systems with Applications, 2012
- Decision-making with distance measures and induced aggregation operatorsComputers & Industrial Engineering, 2011
- A note on permutations and rank aggregationMathematical and Computer Modelling, 2010
- A note on generalized rank aggregationInformation Processing Letters, 2009
- Approximate and dynamic rank aggregationTheoretical Computer Science, 2004
- Necessary and sufficient conditions for a resolution of the social choice paradoxJournal of Economic Theory, 1983