Communal Harmony as Governmentality: Reciprocity, peace-keeping, state legitimacy, and citizenship in contemporary India
- 20 August 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Modern Asian Studies
- Vol. 49 (2) , 393-429
Abstract
Debates about secularism in post-independence India have often revolved around the visions of two of the country's founding fathers—M. K. Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru. A sharp distinction is drawn between them by those who argue that the Gandhian model (or, what in common parlance and state discourses is called communal harmony) stems from Indian cultural and religious values, and lies beyond the realm of the state. The Nehruvian model, however, is a state project through and through. This article transcends this dichotomy to show that the association of Nehru and Gandhi with these models does not necessarily mean that secularism and communal harmony faithfully reflect their ideas and, despite the differences in their aims and methods, both models are united in the discourses and practices of the state as strategies of ‘governmentality’. After redefining the core of communal harmony as reciprocity (rather than tolerance), I show how it is performed, how it supplements the state's efforts to keep the peace in a religiously plural society by the force of law, and shores up the state's legitimacy deficit. However, the state's simultaneous involvement in Nehruvian and Gandhian projects is not an innocuous fact because it undermines the state's constitutional and secular obligations to non-discriminatory citizenship in the Indian nation. The argument is that the state's endorsement ofdargah-centred Islamic piety as an exemplary site of communal harmony and particular ideas of the Indian nation legitimized by communal harmony ‘problematizes’ the national belonging of certain kinds of pious Muslims.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sufis, Scholars and Scapegoats: Rashīd Aḥmad Gangohī (d. 1905) and the Deobandi Critique of SufismThe Muslim World, 2009
- Sufism and Revivalism in South Asia: Mawl?n? Ashraf ‘Al? Th?nv? of Deoband and Mawl?n? Aḥmad Raz? Kh?n of Bareilly and their paradigms of Islamic revivalismThe Muslim World, 2009
- Stoking the Flames: Intra-Muslim Rivalries in India and the Saudi ConnectionComparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East, 2007
- An Outline of a Revisionist Theory of ModernityEuropean Journal of Sociology, 2006
- On the enchantment of the state: Indian thought on the role of the state in the narrative of modernityEuropean Journal of Sociology, 2006
- Gandhi's Politics: Liberalism and the Question of the AshramSouth Atlantic Quarterly, 2002
- Can a Muslim Be an Indian?Comparative Studies in Society and History, 1999
- The twilight of certitudes: Secularism, Hindu nationalism and other masks of deculturationPostcolonial Studies, 1998
- Auerbach in Istanbul: Edward Said, Secular Criticism, and the Question of Minority CultureCritical Inquiry, 1998
- On the moral perils of exchange1989