Relationships Between the Thurstone, Coombs, and Rasch Approaches to Itenl Scaling
- 1 September 1984
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Applied Psychological Measurement
- Vol. 8 (4) , 373-383
Abstract
Andrich (1978) derived a formal equivalency be tween Thurstone's Case V specialization of the law of comparative judgment for paired comparisons, with a logistic function substituted for the normal, and the Rasch model for direct responses. The equivalency was corroborated by a specific substantial-psychologi cal interpretation of the Rasch binary item response probability. Studying the relationships between the Thurstone and Rasch models from another perspective than Andrich's, namely, from a data-theoretical point of view, it appears that the equivalency is based on an implicit assumption with respect to the subject popula tion. This assumption (1) is rather restrictive, and therefore its empirical validity seems to be low, and (2) seems to contradict the substantial reasoning corro borating the Thurstone-Rasch equivalency. It is argued that the Thurstone model cannot be considered the sample-independent pair comparison counterpart of the Rasch model. An alternative pair comparison equiva lent of the Rasch model is tentatively proposed. Fi nally, the theoretical and practical implications of An drich's and of the present study are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- A New Derivation of the Rasch Model1984
- Logistic Latent Trait Models with Linear ConstraintsPsychometrika, 1983
- Marginal Maximum Likelihood Estimation for the One-Parameter Logistic ModelPsychometrika, 1982
- Marginal Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Item Parameters: Application of an EM AlgorithmPsychometrika, 1981
- Testing and obtaining fit of data to the Rasch modelBritish Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 1980
- Relationships Between the Thurstone and Rasch Approaches to Item ScalingApplied Psychological Measurement, 1978
- Paired Comparisons with Individual DifferencesPsychometrika, 1976
- Probabilistic UnfoldingPsychometrika, 1973
- A Goodness of Fit Test for the Rasch ModelPsychometrika, 1973
- Composite measurementJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 1969