A Systematic Review of the Qualitative Evidence for the Use of Lifestyle Planning in People with Learning Disabilities
Authors:
- 1 September 1999
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Learning Disabilities for Nursing, Health, and Social Care
- Vol. 3 (3) , 148-158
Abstract
Lifestyle planning (LP) for people with learning disabilities is largely supported by qualitative rather than quantitative research. LP is a time-consuming and potentially resource-intensive area of practice which is becoming more prevalent in the UK. We present the first systematic review of the qualitative evidence base for the use of LP in people with learning disabilities. Such evidence concerns the special characteristics of LP and its outcomes in descriptive rather than quantitative terms. Qualitative research is usually aimed at enhancing validity by grounding theory in data collected. Twenty-one studies passed eligibility criteria for inclusion in this review, but only ten provided any outcome data, the others being concerned with process only. A replicable search strategy was employed and the resulting original data sources were critically reviewed with respect to major concepts and categories in the areas of: planning process, choices and preferences, ethics and outcomes. Explicitly person-centred approaches such as essential lifestyle planning are contrasted with more service-led methods such as individual programme planning. There are major methodological limitations in much of the available literature and suggestions for future research to clarify matters are made. The current evidence base suggests that no form of LP has significantly better outcomes than any other form and that it is not clear if LP in general enhances outcomes. Ongoing use of person centred planning in particular is informed by ethical considerations and is evolving in its structure and function.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Paradigms in Intellectual Disability: Compare, Contrast, CombineJournal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 1998
- 'What do you think?': a qualitative approach to evaluating individual planning servicesJournal of Intellectual Disability Research, 1997
- Using person-centered planning to determine employment preferences among people with the most severe developmental disabilitiesJournal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 1997
- A model system for the evaluation of Individual Program PlansJournal of Intellectual & Developmental Disability, 1996
- Using person-centered planning concepts to enhance school-to-adult life transition planningJournal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 1996
- An Evaluation of Joint Training for Staff and Clients in Shared Action Planning in SolihullBritish Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1995
- INDIVIDUAL PROGRAMME PLANS: EVALUATION AND DEVELOPMENT IN A HOSPITAL SETTINGThe British Journal of Development Disabilities, 1995
- EDITORIALThe Lancet, 1995
- Validation of technical criteria for setting IPP goals for persons with developmental disabilities in residential settingsBehavioral Interventions, 1994
- ASSESSING CLIENT PARTICIPATION IN MENTAL HANDICAP SERVICES: A PILOT STUDYThe British Journal of Mental Subnormality, 1990