Diversifying the Principal Pipeline Amid Anti-DEI Legislations: Recommendations for Principal Preparation Programs
- 24 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of School Leadership
- Vol. 36 (1) , 46-70
Abstract
Despite students of color comprising more than half of the K–12 student population, the principal pipeline remains predominantly white, with roughly four of five principals identifying as such. This demographic mismatch has been linked to the inequitable experiences and outcomes for students of color, suggesting that the disproportionately white principal pipeline is failing to meet their needs. As gatekeepers, principal preparation programs are tasked with remedying this incongruence by increasing the recruitment and admission of teachers of color for leadership preparation. Conflicting with these expectations, are recent attacks on diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) at the federal, state, and local levels, seeking to undermine these efforts. In this essay, a review of the literature on recruitment and admission practices across principal preparation programs was undertaken to explore the strategies used by scholars to support efforts to diversify the principal pipeline. Recommendations are presented to guide principal preparation programs’ “tactful” navigation of anti-DEI legislations across three areas. Implications are also offered for policy and future research.Keywords
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- “It Feels Like White Supremacy Losing Control”: Gleaning Local Perspectives on “Anti-Woke” LegislationThe Journal of Race, Ethnicity, and Politics, 2025
- “We’re on Our Own Out Here”: Faculty Member Responses to Legislative Threats to Academic Freedom and Scholarship on RaceThe Journal of Higher Education, 2025
- Critically framing Florida’s anti-Woke education reform movementJournal of Educational Administration and History, 2024
- Attributes of Highly Diverse Principal Preparation Programs: Pre-enrollment to Post-completionLeadership and Policy in Schools, 2022
- Cultivating Racial Diversity or Reproducing Whiteness?: A QuantCrit Analysis of School Districts’ Early Principal Hiring PracticesLeadership and Policy in Schools, 2022
- Increasing School Leader Diversity in a Social Justice Context: Revisiting Strategies for Leadership Preparation ProgramsLeadership and Policy in Schools, 2022
- Why a Diverse Leadership Pipeline Matters: The Empirical EvidenceLeadership and Policy in Schools, 2022
- THE VALUE OF IDEOLOGICAL DIVERSITY AMONG UNIVERSITY FACULTYSocial Philosophy and Policy, 2020
- Desegregation and the (Dis)Integration of Black School Leaders: Reflections on the Impact ofBrown v. Board of Educationon Black EducationPeabody Journal of Education, 2019
- Battling inertia in educational leadership: CRT Praxis for race conscious dialogueRace Ethnicity and Education, 2014