What can and can't we say about indirect land‐use change in Brazil using an integrated economic – land‐use change model?
Open Access
- 19 June 2015
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in GCB Bioenergy
- Vol. 8 (3) , 561-578
Abstract
It is commonly recognized that large uncertainties exist in modelled biofuel‐induced indirect land‐use change, but until now, spatially explicit quantification of such uncertainties by means of error propagation modelling has never been performed. In this study, we demonstrate a general methodology to stochastically calculate direct and indirect land‐use change (dLUCandiLUC) caused by an increasing demand for biofuels, with an integrated economic – land‐use change model. We use the global Computable General Equilibrium model MAGNET, connected to the spatially explicit land‐use change modelPLUC. We quantify important uncertainties in the modelling chain. Next,dLUCandiLUCprojections for Brazil up to 2030 at different spatial scales and the uncertainty herein are assessed. Our results show that cell‐based (5 × 5 km2) probabilities ofdLUCrange from 0 to 0.77, and ofiLUCfrom 0 to 0.43, indicating that it is difficult to project exactly wheredLUCandiLUCwill occur, with more difficulties foriLUCthan fordLUC. At country level,dLUCarea can be projected with high certainty, having a coefficient of variation (cv) of only 0.02, whileiLUCarea is still uncertain, having a cv of 0.72. The latter means that, considering the 95% confidence interval, theiLUCarea in Brazil might be 2.4 times as high or as low as the projected mean. Because this confidence interval is so wide that it is likely to straddle any legislation threshold, our opinion is that threshold evaluation foriLUCindicators should not be implemented in legislation. For future studies, we emphasize the need for provision of quantitative uncertainty estimates together with the calculatedLUCindicators, to allow users to evaluate the reliability of these indicators and the effects of their uncertainty on the impacts of land‐use change, such as greenhouse gas emissions.Keywords
Funding Information
- FES subsidy from the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs, Agriculture, and Innovation (EL&I)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Macro-economic impact of large-scale deployment of biomass resources for energy and materials on a national level—A combined approach for the NetherlandsEnergy Policy, 2013
- Remote Sensing Time Series to Evaluate Direct Land Use Change of Recent Expanded Sugarcane Crop in BrazilSustainability, 2012
- Reconciling top-down and bottom-up modelling on future bioenergy deploymentNature Climate Change, 2012
- The Soy Moratorium in the Amazon Biome Monitored by Remote Sensing ImagesRemote Sensing, 2011
- An overview of biofuel policies across the worldEnergy Policy, 2010
- Studies on the Rapid Expansion of Sugarcane for Ethanol Production in São Paulo State (Brazil) Using Landsat DataRemote Sensing, 2010
- Indirect land-use changes can overcome carbon savings from biofuels in BrazilProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2010
- Exploring spatial data uncertainties in land‐use change scenariosInternational Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2008
- Wavelet analysis of MODIS time series to detect expansion and intensification of row-crop agriculture in BrazilRemote Sensing of Environment, 2008
- Econometric policy evaluation: A critiqueCarnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 1976