Eyeballing: the use of visual appearance to diagnose ‘sick’
- 31 July 2017
- journal article
- diagnostic reasoning
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 51 (11) , 1138-1145
Abstract
Context: Prior studies suggest that clinicians can categorise patients in an emergency room as ‘sick’ or ‘not sick’ using rapid visual assessment. The rapid nature of these decisions suggests clinicians are relying on pattern recognition or System 1 processing; however, this has not been studied experimentally. In this study, we explore the accuracy of these decisions using patient disposition (discharge, admission to ward or admission to critical care) as an objective outcome, and collect evidence to argue for the use of System 1 processing in the ‘sick’ or ‘not sick’ decision process. Methods: Fourteen practising emergency physicians reviewed 25 videos of patients presenting to the emergency room. They were asked to predict patient disposition (discharge, admission to ward or admission to critical care) and estimate whether they were ‘sick’ or ‘not sick’ using a continuous slider on a ‘sick’ scale from ‘not sick’ (0) to ‘sick’ (100). We collected decision time and asked physicians to identify how they came to the decision using a continuous slider on a ‘system processing’ scale from ‘knew immediately’ (0) to ‘deliberated intently’ (1). Results: Inter‐rater reliability judging ‘sick’ was computed as an intraclass correlation coefficient ( ICC ) of 0.54. Agreement among physicians in predicting disposition was 68% with ICC of 0.44, and accuracy at predicting disposition was 55%. Physicians made their decision in an average of 10 – 11 seconds and rated 70% of their decisions as < 0.5 on the scale from ‘knew immediately’ (0) to ‘deliberated intently’ (1). Conclusions: Experienced emergency physicians are able to visually assess patients rapidly and predict disposition in a very short time, albeit with fair reliability and lower accuracy than reported previously. Subjectively, they reported that the majority of decisions were on the side of ‘knew immediately’, consistent with the application of System 1 processing.Keywords
Funding Information
- McMaster University
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Causes of Errors in Clinical Reasoning: Cognitive Biases, Knowledge Deficits, and Dual Process ThinkingAcademic Medicine, 2017
- Examining the Influence of Context and Professional Culture on Clinical Reasoning Through Rhetorical-Narrative AnalysisQualitative Health Research, 2016
- Accuracy of ‘My Gut Feeling:’ Comparing System 1 to System 2 Decision-Making for Acuity Prediction, Disposition and Diagnosis in an Academic Emergency DepartmentWestern Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2015
- “Sick” or “not-sick”: accuracy of System 1 diagnostic reasoning for the prediction of disposition and acuity in patients presenting to an academic EDThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2013
- Mapping Out the Emergency Department Disposition Decision for High-Acuity PatientsAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2012
- The ‘sense of alarm’ (‘gut feeling’) in clinical practice. A survey among European general practitioners on recognition and expressionEuropean Journal of General Practice, 2010
- Dual processing and diagnostic errorsAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2009
- Dual-Processing Accounts of Reasoning, Judgment, and Social CognitionAnnual Review of Psychology, 2008
- The Aging PhysicianAcademic Medicine, 2002
- Effect of processing strategy on diagnostic skill in dermatologyAcademic Medicine, 1994